Watch the episode here:
Listen to the podcast here:
Ugbaad Kosar, director of equity and justice at Carbon180, explains how carbon removal can be credible, accountable, and shaped by the communities that live next to it. Host Corinna Bellizzi and Ugbaad explore land-based and technological approaches, real community benefits, and what neighbors can do when a project is proposed nearby.
Director of Equity and Justice, Carbon180 · Environmental Scientist and Policy Advocate
Cutting emissions is the first job, but scientists say we also need to remove carbon that is already in the air, and how we do it will decide whether people trust it. Ugbaad Kosar brings a human-rights lens to the question, shaped by the 2011 drought and famine that reached her family in Somalia. In this conversation she explains the range of carbon removal approaches, from soil and forests to direct air capture and the ocean, and why the land-based options may be the ones ready to go today. She also makes the case that community input is not a courtesy but a requirement, with data centers as a real-time lesson, and shares what Carbon180’s CORE framework asks of anyone building a project. You will leave with practical ways to get informed and speak up when a project is proposed near you.
Full Episode Transcript: For those with audio or other accessibility concerns, the complete time-stamped transcript is included at the end of the blog post summary.
Show Note:
00:00 – Why Land-Based Carbon Removal Benefits Go Beyond Carbon
00:28 – Introduction to Care More Be Better
00:47 – Meet Ugbaad Kosar: Equity and Justice at Carbon180
02:26 – Ugbaad’s Journey Into Climate Science and Environmental Justice
06:07 – What Is Carbon Removal and Why Do We Need It?
08:01 – Why Carbon Removal Must Work Alongside Emissions Reduction
09:50 – Iceland’s Circular Carbon Removal and Algae Project
14:14 – Why Carbon Removal Requires a Portfolio of Solutions
15:10 – Exploring Carbon Removal Technologies and Their Potential
18:00 – Land-Based Carbon Removal: Practical Solutions We Can Scale Today
22:03 – Ocean-Based Carbon Removal: Opportunities and Uncertainties
25:48 – The Hidden Benefits of Regenerative Agriculture
26:32 – Technology-Based Carbon Removal and Community Benefits
28:34 – What Data Centers Teach Us About Community Engagement
32:05 – Creating Meaningful Benefits for Local Communities
37:47 – Supporting Farmers Through the Transition to Regenerative Practices
39:55 – Building Equity and Justice Into Carbon Removal
40:16 – Carbon180’s Community Regranting Program
43:15 – Bringing Science, Innovation, Equity, and Justice Together
47:23 – Introducing the CORE Carbon Removal Framework
50:56 – Transparency and Accountability in Climate Projects
52:46 – How Individuals Can Support Responsible Carbon Removal
55:11 – What Gives Ugbaad Hope for the Future?
56:37 – Closing Thoughts and Supporting Prescott College
About Ugbaad Kosar

Ugbaad Kosar is the Director of Equity and Justice at Carbon180, where she leads the organization’s equity and justice program. Her work focuses on ensuring that carbon removal is credible, accountable, and shaped by the communities most impacted by climate solutions. With more than eight years of interdisciplinary experience in environmental science research, policy development, advocacy, and data analysis,
Ugbaad works to advance inclusive and equitable climate policy. Previously, she worked for the City of Ottawa, informing municipal and provincial environmental legislation, and developed policy for both a grassroots organization and the City of Edmonton.
Ugbaad holds a dual Master of Science in forest sciences and renewable resource management from the University of Alberta and the University of Freiburg, as well as a bachelor’s degree from Carleton University. Her writing has appeared in The Hill and Electricity Journal.
Connect with Ugbaad Kosar
Learn More
Carbon180 also publishes The Carbon Copy, a weekly news roundup, at Carbon180.org.
CONNECT & SUPPORT CARE MORE BE BETTER
Substack: https://caremorebebetter.substack.com
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/caremorebebetter
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@caremorebebetter
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/caremorebebetter
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/CareMoreBeBetter
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/care-more-be-better
CAUSE PARTNER: If you value open dialogue, sustainability, and social equity, I invite you to support our new cause partner —Prescott College. To learn more about this effort and to support the show, visit: https://caremorebebetter.com/support/
Carbon Removal, Done Right: Equity, Community, and Accountability with Ugbaad Kosar

Why Carbon Removal Matters and Why the Approach Matters
Welcome, Regenerators! Each week, we explore the intersection of sustainability, justice, and regenerative thinking to build a better future for people and the planet.
Cutting greenhouse gas emissions is essential to addressing climate change. But even if the world makes significant progress in reducing emissions, carbon dioxide already released into the atmosphere will continue affecting the climate. That is why scientists emphasize the need for carbon removal alongside emissions reductions.
But removing carbon is not simply a matter of developing new technologies or building facilities. We also need to consider where these projects happen, who makes the decisions, who benefits, and whether the communities living nearby have a meaningful voice.
Ugbaad Kosar, Director of Equity and Justice at Carbon180, works at the center of these questions. Her work focuses on making sure carbon removal develops in ways that are responsible, transparent, and accountable to the people most affected.
In this episode of Care More Be Better, we explore the different approaches to carbon removal, the importance of community participation, the challenges of emerging technologies, and how equity and justice can be built into climate solutions from the beginning.
From Environmental Science to a Human Rights Perspective on Climate Change
Ugbaad’s path into environmental science and climate policy began during her undergraduate studies. Initially, she was interested in the environment but had not yet settled on a specific career direction. Studying environmental science introduced her to climate projections and the potential consequences of continued emissions and environmental degradation.
At the time, climate change could feel like a future problem something that would happen years down the road if humanity did not change course.
That perspective changed in 2011. Ugbaad’s family has roots in Somalia, in East Africa, and that year the region experienced an unprecedented drought that contributed to widespread famine. Members of her extended family were directly affected.
The experience connected the scientific information she was studying to the real lives of people experiencing climate impacts. Climate change was no longer just a projection, a model, or a collection of numbers. It was affecting families and communities in the present.
That experience helped shape the human rights perspective she brings to climate action today. It also reinforced an important principle: climate solutions must account for the people experiencing the consequences, particularly communities that are often left out of decision-making.
What Is Carbon Removal?
Carbon removal refers to approaches that take carbon dioxide already present in the atmosphere and store it away, ideally for a meaningful period of time.
It is important to distinguish carbon removal from emissions reduction. Reducing emissions means preventing additional greenhouse gases from entering the atmosphere. Carbon removal addresses some of the carbon that has already accumulated.
Both are necessary parts of a comprehensive climate response.
Carbon removal can take many forms. Trees and forests naturally absorb carbon dioxide through photosynthesis, while healthy soils can store significant amounts of carbon. Agricultural practices can help protect and increase that stored carbon. Other approaches use technology and chemical processes to capture carbon directly from the air.
These approaches are not interchangeable. Each has different requirements, potential benefits, limitations, and environmental considerations.
Ugbaad emphasizes that carbon removal should not become an excuse to continue relying on fossil fuels or delay the transition to renewable energy. The goal should be to reduce emissions while also developing responsible ways to remove carbon that is already in the atmosphere.
In other words, carbon removal and emissions reduction need to work together rather than compete for attention.

Image courtesy of Carbon180
Carbon Removal Requires a Portfolio of Solutions
One of the important ideas in this conversation is that carbon removal should not depend on a single technology or intervention.
There are land-based approaches, ocean-based approaches, and technology-based approaches. Each has a different level of maturity, research, and understanding of its potential impacts.
Land-based approaches include forest management, soil restoration, cover cropping, and rotational grazing. Many of these practices already exist and can be expanded with appropriate funding, coordination, and support for the people managing the land.

Image courtesy of Carbon180
Technology-based approaches include direct air capture and enhanced rock weathering. These approaches may offer additional opportunities for removing carbon at scale, but they also raise questions about energy use, water consumption, infrastructure, location, and community impacts.

Image courtesy of Carbon180
Ocean-based approaches include protecting coastal ecosystems such as mangroves, wetlands, and seagrasses, as well as emerging approaches such as ocean alkalinity enhancement and kelp sinking.
Rather than putting all available resources into one solution, a diverse portfolio can help address different parts of the climate challenge. It also creates opportunities to learn which approaches work best in different environments and communities.
The challenge is making sure that each approach is evaluated carefully and developed responsibly.
Why Land-Based Carbon Removal Offers More Than Carbon Benefits
Land-based carbon removal can provide benefits that extend well beyond the amount of carbon stored.

Image courtesy of Carbon180
Practices such as cover cropping, rotational grazing, and improved soil management can help improve soil health, support biodiversity, and reduce reliance on chemical inputs. Healthy soils can retain more water, which can help farms become more resilient to drought and flooding.
These practices can also support beneficial insects and pollinators, reduce agricultural runoff, and contribute to healthier ecosystems.
Ugbaad notes that farmers are often interested in these approaches because of the practical benefits they can provide. Carbon storage may be an additional advantage rather than the primary reason for adopting a new practice.

Image courtesy of Carbon180
For farmers, improving soil quality, reducing input costs, and protecting long-term productivity can be more immediate concerns than carbon measurements.
However, transitioning to new agricultural practices is not always easy. Farmers often operate with narrow financial margins, and changes to soil management can take several years to show their full benefits. During that transition, they may need financial assistance, technical support, and reliable information.
Farmer-to-farmer education can also make a difference. Trusted agricultural networks and experienced practitioners can explain new practices in ways that connect with the everyday realities of farming.
Supporting land-based carbon removal therefore requires more than encouraging farmers to change. It means creating the financial and educational conditions that make those changes possible.
The Promise and Uncertainty of Ocean-Based Carbon Removal
Ocean-based carbon removal is an emerging area with significant potential, but it also requires careful research.
Some approaches focus on protecting coastal ecosystems that naturally store carbon, including mangroves, wetlands, and seagrasses. Other approaches involve more experimental interventions, such as ocean alkalinity enhancement and kelp sinking.

Image courtesy of Carbon180
The ocean is an interconnected and open system. Changes in one area can have consequences that extend beyond the immediate location of a project. That makes it especially important to understand possible environmental impacts before attempting to scale these approaches.
Ugbaad explains that there is still considerable uncertainty around marine carbon removal. More research is needed to understand what these interventions might do, what risks they could create, and how their effectiveness can be measured.
Carbon180 has supported efforts to advance research and development in this area, including work around the proposed Rescue Oceans Act, which focuses on building a stronger understanding of ocean-based carbon removal.
The broader lesson is that promising technologies should not move forward simply because they offer an exciting possibility. They need evidence, careful evaluation, and safeguards that account for the complexity of marine ecosystems.
Community Acceptance Must Be Part of Climate Technology
A carbon removal project can have a strong technical foundation and still create problems if the surrounding community is not meaningfully involved.
Facilities may require substantial energy and water resources. Some technologies can generate noise, require significant infrastructure, or change the character of the areas where they are located.
These concerns are not separate from climate action. They are part of determining whether a project is responsible and sustainable.
Ugbaad draws a connection between carbon removal and the current public discussion around data centers. In many communities, residents have raised concerns about noise pollution, air quality, water use, and the way development decisions are made.
A recurring problem is that communities may not be involved early enough in the planning process. By the time residents learn about a project, important decisions may already have been made.
This can lead to opposition, delays, and a loss of trust.
The same risk exists for carbon removal projects. Community participation should begin during research, development, and planning not only after a company has selected a site or finalized its plans.
Early engagement allows residents to identify concerns, contribute local knowledge, and influence how projects are designed. It can also help developers understand what communities actually need rather than making assumptions about what would benefit them.
What Does a Real Community Benefit Look Like?
One of the most important questions in responsible carbon removal is how to define community benefits.
It is easy for a company or developer to assume that a particular project will create benefits for nearby residents. But the people living in those communities may have very different priorities.
A useful analogy discussed in the episode compares community benefits to ordering a meal at a restaurant. If a restaurant gets the order wrong and brings an unexpected dessert to make up for it, that dessert may not be useful to the customer. The customer may not even be able to eat it.
The same principle applies to community engagement. Providing something that a community never asked for does not automatically create a meaningful benefit.
Instead, project developers need to ask residents what matters to them and make sure their input can influence the outcome.
Some communities may prioritize well-paying, high-quality jobs with safe working conditions and union protections. Others may focus on environmental improvements, local investment, public health, or opportunities for greater decision-making power.
There is no universal definition that works for every location.
Ugbaad emphasizes that meaningful participation is not simply about giving people an opportunity to speak. Communities need some level of influence over decisions, and developers must be honest about which parts of a project can still change.
Transparency is also essential. Companies should communicate what they know, what they do not know, and what remains uncertain. Making promises that cannot be kept can undermine trust and create long-term problems.
Building Equity Into Carbon Removal From the Beginning
At Carbon180, Ugbaad has worked to create opportunities for community-based organizations to become more involved in the carbon removal field.
One example is a regranting program she helped establish approximately five years ago. Rather than expecting communities to react to new projects without preparation, the program provides funding to smaller community-based organizations so they can learn about carbon removal and build their capacity to participate.
The program supports introductory education, knowledge-sharing, and opportunities for organizations to understand the technologies and policies being developed.
It also creates a two-way learning process. Community organizations share their experiences, priorities, and concerns, helping Carbon180 better understand what responsible carbon removal should look like in practice.
The results have extended beyond education. People from grassroots movements and community organizations have become more active in the carbon removal field. Some have contributed to policy discussions, helped write or review legislation, served on company boards, and developed recommendations for how projects should be designed.
This represents an important shift. Communities that may previously have been expected to respond to decisions made elsewhere are gaining more opportunities to shape those decisions themselves.
For Ugbaad, this is a central part of building a more equitable carbon removal movement: people who are likely to experience the impacts should also have a meaningful role in developing the solutions.
Bringing Science, Innovation, Equity, and Justice Together
Responsible carbon removal requires collaboration between people who may approach the same problem from very different perspectives.
Scientific and innovation teams often focus on technical performance, measurement, verification, and the ability to reach carbon removal targets. Equity and justice teams may focus on community participation, power dynamics, accountability, and the distribution of benefits and risks.
These priorities do not have to conflict.
Ugbaad describes how bringing these perspectives together at Carbon180 has encouraged teams to better understand one another’s language and assumptions. Many disagreements can begin with people using the same words but attaching different meanings to them.
Taking the time to clarify those differences can improve collaboration and help teams identify solutions that account for more than one perspective.
This is especially important when balancing speed and scale with meaningful community participation. A project may appear to move faster when community engagement is treated as a separate activity or postponed until later. But failing to involve people early can lead to opposition, delays, and costly changes further down the line.
Integrating equity and justice into the early stages of development can help projects avoid preventable mistakes and build stronger relationships.
Measurement and verification are equally important. If a project claims to remove carbon, it needs to demonstrate that it actually does so and that the carbon remains stored as intended.
That information should also be communicated in ways that ordinary people can understand. Data and technical reports are important, but they should not become barriers that prevent communities from learning what is happening around them.
The CORE Carbon Removal Framework: Defining Responsible Carbon Removal
As the carbon removal field grows, different organizations and stakeholders increasingly use terms such as equity, justice, transparency, and accountability. However, these terms can mean different things to policymakers, investors, scientists, and community-based organizations.
That lack of shared understanding can make collaboration difficult.
To address this challenge, Carbon180 introduced the CORE Carbon Removal Framework in April 2026. The framework is designed to provide practical definitions, principles, resources, and examples that help people understand what responsible carbon removal looks like.
Rather than treating responsible carbon removal as a collection of broad promises, the framework connects principles with practical applications.
It addresses important considerations such as justice, equity, accountability, and enforcement, alongside technical questions about whether carbon removal is genuinely additional and whether the carbon will remain stored as intended.
It also includes practices related to community benefit mechanisms, knowledge-building, and workforce development.
Case studies help demonstrate how these ideas can be applied in real projects and across different stages of development.
The framework is intended to be a living resource that can support different participants in the carbon removal field, helping them work from a clearer understanding of what responsible development requires.
You can explore the framework at Carbon180’s CORE Carbon Removal Framework.
Transparency and Accountability Should Be Accessible to Everyone
For someone living near a proposed carbon removal facility, transparency should mean being able to find clear and useful information about what is happening.
That information should not be hidden behind complicated technical reports, difficult-to-find website pages, or requests that require residents to contact multiple organizations.
People should be able to understand how decisions are being made, what data is being collected, and what the project is expected to do.
Companies can work with local governments and community organizations to make information accessible. They can also communicate regularly with residents and make it clear where people can find updates.
Accountability means more than making commitments. Projects need ways to demonstrate whether those commitments are being met.
If a company says it will remove a certain amount of carbon, it should be able to provide evidence. If it promises particular community benefits, there should be a way to evaluate whether those benefits are actually being delivered.
Making this information accessible helps build trust and gives communities the ability to participate with a clearer understanding of what is happening.
What Can Individuals Do to Support Responsible Carbon Removal?
People do not need to be climate scientists or policy experts to become involved in responsible carbon removal.
Ugbaad identifies several practical starting points.
First, learn what carbon removal actually means. Understand the different approaches, where they are being developed, and how they differ in terms of maturity, environmental impacts, and potential community benefits.
Second, explore the resources available through Carbon180. Its website provides information about carbon removal technologies, policy, and the development of responsible approaches.
Third, connect with local community-based organizations. These groups may already understand the environmental and social issues affecting a particular area. They can help people learn about local developments and identify opportunities to participate.
If a carbon removal project is proposed near your community, it is also important to understand the local decision-making process. Contact local government representatives, find out whether public hearings have taken place, and learn when upcoming meetings or opportunities for public comment are scheduled.
Asking questions is a valuable part of participation. Residents can seek information about water and energy use, potential environmental impacts, job opportunities, community benefits, and how project performance will be measured.
The goal is not automatically to support or oppose every proposed project. It is to make sure decisions are informed, transparent, and shaped by the people who will experience their consequences.
What Gives Hope for the Future of Carbon Removal?
Despite the challenges, Ugbaad sees reasons for optimism.
Over the past eight years, she has witnessed a shift in how the carbon removal field approaches equity and justice. More organizations and individuals are paying attention to the potential impacts on communities and the importance of building responsible projects.
There is still significant work to do, but the field is developing at a stage where it can learn from mistakes made in other areas of climate and infrastructure development.
That creates an opportunity to build something different from the beginning one where technical innovation and community participation are not competing priorities.
For Ugbaad, the most encouraging possibility is that people increasingly recognize that climate solutions must work for both the planet and the communities who live on it.
Environmental justice communities have often carried a disproportionate share of environmental burdens while having limited influence over the decisions that affect them. A more responsible approach to carbon removal must change that relationship.
The opportunity is to create climate solutions that remove carbon, protect ecosystems, support communities, and build trust through accountability.
Building Climate Solutions That Put People and the Planet First
Carbon removal may become an important part of addressing climate change, but its success cannot be measured only by the amount of carbon captured or stored.
The way projects are developed matters. Communities need access to information, opportunities to influence decisions, and a clear understanding of the risks and benefits. Companies and policymakers need to be accountable for the promises they make.
Ugbaad Kosar’s work at Carbon180 highlights why equity and justice must be part of climate innovation from the beginning, not added after the major decisions have already been made.
A better climate future requires more than new technology. It requires collaboration, transparency, meaningful participation, and a willingness to learn from the people most affected.
The question is not simply whether we can remove carbon. It is whether we can do it in a way that genuinely benefits people and the planet.
Take Action: Learn More About Responsible Carbon Removal
If you want to understand how carbon removal can be developed responsibly, explore the resources from Carbon180:
You can also follow Carbon180’s The Carbon Copy for a weekly roundup of carbon removal news and developments.
Support Care More Be Better
At Care More Be Better, we believe that sustainability, justice, and regenerative thinking must work together to create a healthier future for people and the planet.
Our cause partner, Prescott College, prepares people to think systemically and lead regenerative change alongside the communities they serve. Supporting education and community leadership is one way to help create the kind of future we want to see.
If you value open dialogue, sustainability, and social equity, consider supporting the show with a monthly contribution.
Visit CareMoreBeBetter.com/support to learn more and make a contribution.
Together, we can support climate solutions that do more than address carbon. We can help build a future where communities have a voice, ecosystems can thrive, and accountability is part of every step forward.
Care more, be better, and let’s build a regenerative future for people and the planet.
Transcript:
[00:00:09] Ugbaad Kosar: Oftentimes, what leads people to be interested in some of the land-based carbon removal has nothing to do with carbon. It has everything to do with the other co-benefits that come that are central, and they view carbon as the co-benefit. It’s kind of like, oh, that’s a great add-on to what we were already trying to do, which was improve our bottom lines and reducing our pesticides or our other inputs.
[00:00:33] Intro / Outro: Welcome to Care More, Be Better, a podcast for people like you who care about the social impact of conscious companies and everyday heroes. Hear inspiring stories from those who put people and planet before profit and personal gain. You’ll learn how you can make a difference, vote with your dollars, and get involved today.
Here’s your host, Corinna Bellizzi.
[00:00:57] Corinna Bellizzi: Welcome, Regenerators. Each week, we explore the intersection of sustainability, justice, and regenerative thinking so that we can build a better future for people and planet. Cutting emissions is the first job in the fight against climate change. But scientists also tell us that we will need to remove carbon dioxide that is already in the air, and how we do that really matters Who decides where it happens?
Who benefits? Who is listening to the people who live next door? Ugbad Kozar is the director of equity and justice at Carbon180, a nonprofit that works to build the carbon removal field through policy. She leads work to make sure carbon removal is credible, accountable, and shaped by the communities most impacted, from strengthening community capacity to advancing inclusive governance, and also improving how carbon removal efforts are evaluated.
She brings more than eight years of experience in environmental science, research, policy, advocacy, and data analysis. She has worked for the City of Ottawa in forming municipal and provincial environmental legislation, and developed policy for a grassroots organization and for the City of Edmonton. She holds a dual master of science in both forest sciences and renewable resources.
Both of these are from the University of Alberta and the University of Freiburg. Her writing has appeared in The Hill and Electricity Journal. I hope you’ll join me in welcoming her to the show. Ugbad, it’s so nice to have you here today.
[00:02:36] Ugbaad Kosar: It is such a pleasure. Thank you so much for inviting me on.
[00:02:39] Corinna Bellizzi: You know, I have so many questions, but I’d like to first start with what led you to where you are here and now.
It seems like you’ve traversed both space and time. And a lot of effort in that space.
[00:02:51] Ugbaad Kosar: Yes, absolutely. It’s been an interesting non-linear journey for me. Uh, I think the start of getting into just the climate, uh, conservation, environmental science space really happened during my undergrad. Um, I kind of fumbled into environmental science, truthfully.
I was kind of interested in it and, like most 17-year-olds, had no idea what I wanted to do with the rest of my life, but needed to make that decision. Um, but I knew I was interested in environmental science, and so that sort of introduced me into this world and this space. But I remember very distinctly during, um, the first year of my undergrad, this was about 2011 at this point, where I was learning about these climate projections, these climate scenarios that were coming, these impending climate crises if we don’t think about our reducing emissions and decarbonizing.
Um, and it felt really far off. It felt like it was, it was coming, but it wasn’t quite here yet. And then subsequently, my family is originally from East Africa, from Somalia, and in 2011 they were hit b- with- What was an unprecedented drought, and that drought led to really significant famine, um, widespread famine.
Um, many of my direct relatives were impacted, and it was 100%, uh, induced by climate change. And so that really sort of brought this human lens into what I was learning and what I was experiencing, and I think it really solidified for me that this isn’t an impending crisis. This is something that’s here, that’s now, that people are experiencing around the world, and really sort of shifted for me this idea of climate scenarios and projections and numbers, and shifted me into this human rights lens of how I view the world and how I view climate action.
Uh, and I’ve just been in this space ever since.
[00:04:45] Corinna Bellizzi: I think it’s important for us to recognize that droughts have often plagued entire regions of the world. Mm-hmm. Opponents of this concept of climate change, which is essentially law as far as I’m concerned. I mean, this is… Humans affect our climate. We have affected our climate since we began manipulating the environment in some capacity, from taking trees down to plowing fields.
We have affected the climate. Now, those effects have grown a lot in the last 100 years especially, and that is affecting how long and how intense our weather systems are, including drought. Mm-hmm. It affects the water cycle, it affects where water goes. It affects life, because life requires water. This is something that is universal.
I recently saw one of my friends post to their, um, page on Instagram and also on TikTok, I think, a comment that they felt they were… That they were speaking a universal truth when they were on their land in Texas praying for rain.
[00:05:46] Ugbaad Kosar: Hmm.
[00:05:46] Corinna Bellizzi: And the perspective they had was that this is probably the most common prayer that humanity has ever put forth.
[00:05:52] Ugbaad Kosar: That resonates a lot. Yes. It is, it is a unifying experience, if anything else, and, and frankly a very humbling experience. It makes you just take a step back and really take in what we have that maybe we take for granted, but also what the potential of what the world could be if we choose the right, make the right decisions, and, and support the people that, that need that support in the process.
[00:06:15] Corinna Bellizzi: Right. Water. Wow. So this gets to my first subject I wanna talk about, which is why carbon removal, and this will connect, I promise, to all of you. So let’s start at the beginning. Mm-hmm. What is carbon removal, and why do scientists say that we need it?
[00:06:35] Ugbaad Kosar: Yes. So I really appreciate that you started off by acknowledging that we need to reduce emissions.
I think that is essential for any sort of, any climate action really. We have to start with what is it that we’re already doing that we can stop doing and that we can reduce doing. Now, even if we were to stop reducing emissions today and we are able to transition off of dependency on fossil fuels and we’re able to decarbonize, there is still so much carbon that has been put out into the atmosphere from decades and decades past that is continuing to wreak havoc on our climate.
So what carbon removal is at its core is trying to pull down that carbon that’s already in the atmosphere and storing it away safely. There are a lot of different ways we can do that, that we can touch on, but at the core it’s really complementing reducing emissions by also looking at what’s already out there and then figuring out different ways.
That can be through trees. We know they do photosynthesis. They already pull down that CO2 from the atmosphere. What are other ways we can support our trees and our forest systems? Agriculture and soil is another really important, uh, carbon sink for us. How do we think about our agricultural practices to help protect that carbon that’s already in soil, and then store it longer term?
And then there’s a lot of really interesting technological approaches that really mess with, um, machinery and then chemical reactions and that sort of thing to do the same thing, so. And, uh, there’s a lot of different ways, but at its core it’s what are we doing with that carbon that’s already out there, and how do we get it out?
[00:08:08] Corinna Bellizzi: I’m involved in a project that is also at this intersection, so I’ll get into that- Oh … a little bit later. Um, some listeners may also wonder whether carbon removal takes attention away from cutting emissions, and that that could be problematic. Oh, we have a solution. We’ll just, you know, solidify it and bury it in our oceans.
One example. How do you see the two working together, and how do we balance the need of both?
[00:08:33] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. Look, as someone who focuses a lot of my time and attention, and career frankly, on carbon removal, I don’t want to see large scale carbon removal that we just have to be dependent on for forever. I want to see us being able to reduce emissions.
I want us to be able to transition to, uh, renewables and strong battery storage and community farms. Like, I think all this stuff is incredibly important, but we have to walk and chew gum at the same time. We have to be able to look at the entirety of the climate crisis and realize that we can do both.
We need to do both. And I think with carbon removal, the more successful we are at when it comes to reducing emissions, the better the chances are for carbon removal. So I think that they are in tandem with one another. I think they need to support one another. Um, and I can completely understand where that concern comes from and, and why that concern is there.
I myself, you know, I hold that. I, I, I hold that tension. But at the end of the day, I also recognize that if we really want to make this world a better place, we’re going to have to do both, and we’re gonna have to be able to use policy, accountability mechanisms, enforcement, whatever it may be, to ensure that we are both reducing emissions and in tandem supporting that carbon removal.
That’s, that’s critical and it’s necessary around the world.
[00:09:56] Corinna Bellizzi: I wanna showcase what I’m working on now because I think it’s a natural point. I’m involved with Vaxa Technologies. I have been for the past six years. Um, they are a company that is focused on creating health and nutrition from algae using today’s energy, and they are co-located with an ON Power plant in Reykjavik, Iceland.
Mm-hmm. At this industrial park, there are several projects being undertaken. You know, this is basically unused, otherwise unused land because it’s, again, close to a geothermal vent where the ON Power power plant is. They’re capturing the energy that comes from the heat of the Earth itself, right?
[00:10:33] Intro / Outro: Mm-hmm.
[00:10:33] Corinna Bellizzi: Along that vent, carbon escapes. So one of the things that carbon, um, that the ON Power project does is that they capture as much of that carbon as possible, and they then feed that carbon to us, which we feed to the algae, right?
[00:10:49] Intro / Outro: Very cool.
[00:10:49] Corinna Bellizzi: So this is like creating this full cycle thing. We also use the water that has been warmed through this vent, um, ’cause we need warm water to grow the algae in.
It can’t be freezing frigid, right? Um, goes through pipes to cool down to a usable temperature, and then we’re utilizing that water to grow our algae. We’re feeding it CO2 that comes through this vent that we’re capturing to prevent it from being, you know, in the atmosphere. So what we’re able to do is by feeding it a solution of NPK, nitrogen, phosphorus, um, potassium, right?
Um, in a solubilized form within the water along with that CO2, is that we’re creating from today’s energy health and nutrition, right?
[00:11:32] Intro / Outro: Yeah.
[00:11:32] Corinna Bellizzi: Now the byproduct becomes a soil amendment that can help actually restore Iceland’s land. Um, if people think about, you know, the Vikings who essentially, you know, raped and pillaged a lot of that area long ago.
They also cut down all the trees of Iceland to make boats, and when they did that, the soil got disrupted and soil went away. So now this volcanic island needs soil restoration. So we have, uh, the byproduct from our spirulina and, um, nanochloropsis algae growth. Mm-hmm. We take that and we spray it onto the soil to encourage, um, the health and nutrition of future plants there.
So now that project is, is taking place. We’re s- locking in carbon for the next 30 years that comes from the byproduct. So it’s like this full cycle- Yeah … circular thing, right? Really cool. At the same time, there is on, at the same facility, um, well, essentially next door but on the same property, not our property, but the same property block so to speak, um, a company that is working to Take carbon out of the atmosphere.
[00:12:39] Intro / Outro: Mm-hmm.
[00:12:39] Corinna Bellizzi: And when they run this equipment, because I’ve been on site when it’s happened, it’s incredibly loud. Mm. I would say it’s probably similar to being next door to a data center. If people are seeing that in the news, it’s just, it’s loud, right? Yeah. So it can’t be that close to, let’s say, where your people are living and whatnot, or it shouldn’t be at least, because it’s disruptive.
Mm-hmm. And it needs to run near constantly, right?
[00:13:02] Intro / Outro: Oh.
[00:13:03] Corinna Bellizzi: So the technologies that are being developed are really cool and creative, and there are projects underway that are doing creative things. So like, hey, let’s, let’s see what we can make from this carbon, right? Mm-hmm. Let’s see what we can produce. Let’s see if we can have an oyster farm instead along all of these different seaboards to help solidify the carbon that’s even in the water so that we can remove it from the, um, ocean and therefore not have super acidic oceans.
Like, there’s all these things that connect together.
[00:13:31] Ugbaad Kosar: Yep.
[00:13:32] Corinna Bellizzi: I’m wondering what your thoughts are presently on where the industry stands.
[00:13:37] Ugbaad Kosar: Mm-hmm.
[00:13:37] Corinna Bellizzi: On how f- feasible some of these technologies are, how close we are to being able to have a solution that is affordable enough to run. Yeah. That can make a measurable difference in the amount of carbon that is presently in our atmosphere, and that can ultimately get us going in a direction where we’re not seeing worsening effects season after season after season.
[00:14:00] Ugbaad Kosar: So many things to- … to, to touch on that. No, I really appreciate that. I think just before I, I dig into what you asked, what I was experiencing while you were sharing your, your, your experience in the space is how interconnected a lot of the different aspects are of the project, and I think that’s a really important piece that I wanna drill home for people.
Carbon removal doesn’t have to be a one singular thing that exists in and of itself. It’s supposed to be a portfolio of different approaches, of different technologies, of different interventions, and it needs to work in tandem with a lot of other climate action. Like, it can’t be something that just exists in its, its own little silo.
So the more we think about integrating what, what do we already have that we are using, what is being wasted that we can harness, um, and, and, and, and create, like, value out of, I think is, is really, really important. So I really appreciated you highlighting that. And to what you were asking about, um, I think it was Project Cypress you were, you were referring to, uh, out in, um, in Iceland, um, by, by Clim- uh, Climeworks, one of the, uh, one of the bigger sort of direct air capture technology- That
[00:15:09] Corinna Bellizzi: sounds right.
Yes.
[00:15:10] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah, that exists. It’s like Iceland, geothermal. It’s, it’s, it’s all clicking for me. Um, I, I think there’s a few things that, that come out for me when I think about what’s ready and how do we know if, like, where the industry is going. I think I always want to drill down again on- Carbon removal spans nature, it spans technology, it can be done on lands, it can be done on oceans.
There’s a lot of different approaches when we talk about carbon removal. So my first instinct is to wonder, okay, are we in a place where, where the communities or people who are living around there are more familiar or more interested in something like direct air capture? Like maybe they have an interest in technology or, or there’s, um, workforce development opportunity.
Whatever it may be that draws folks to that, then we can even go even further in to see there are a lot of different ways to do direct air capture, or there are a lot of different ways to scale up, uh, different technological carbon removal. Um, some may be louder than others. Some may be quieter than others.
Some may be, be able to scale higher, um, or be able to pull down carbon at a faster rate than others. Some have different needs in terms of their energy or in terms of their water usage. So the, the first is kind of just like peeling back that there is a lot of different options that, that are on the table here.
Um, and then the other is there’s a lot of people and a lot of communities that are just more comfortable or more familiar with land-based approaches, and maybe want to lean more into forest management or supporting strong agricultural practices, um, and some of those hybrids. In which case, again, there’s a lot of different ways to do that.
So I guess to start off with is I, I see potential because I see so many different ways to be able to attack this problem. And when I think about how are we going to get to the, the amounts that we need, and I’m not sure if we covered this, but it’s a lot, uh- Yeah … in order for us to… It’s not a small amount of carbon removal we need.
We are talking billions of tons of carbon removal, uh, of, of CO2, and it’s hard to wrap
[00:17:14] Corinna Bellizzi: your
[00:17:14] Ugbaad Kosar: head around that. Let’s help to frame
[00:17:15] Corinna Bellizzi: this. I, I think we need to help frame the practicality for people because-
[00:17:19] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah …
[00:17:19] Corinna Bellizzi: when we talk about things like climate lag, it’s really kind of sounds like doomsday, right? Like- Mm-hmm
there’s almost nothing we can do to prevent weather being worse year after year for the next 30 years.
[00:17:33] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:17:33] Corinna Bellizzi: Because of climate lag, because of the carbon that’s already in the atmosphere, and it’s not just carbon, it’s particulate matter. Yeah. It’s other, um- greenhouse gases- Greenhouse gases … including, like, Freon and refrigerants of all sorts and- Methane
methane, yes. You know- Yeah … all of these things. And so- Yeah … you know, my, my big question has been since the beginning of talks about this technology is, like, how can we lessen that? How can we reduce the time it takes for us to catch up to what the present level- Yeah … of emissions are?
[00:18:04] Ugbaad Kosar: We gotta look at what do we already have that’s ready to go.
[00:18:07] Corinna Bellizzi: Yeah.
[00:18:07] Ugbaad Kosar: And what are things that we can already do? And oftentimes I point people to a lot of those land-based approaches. They’re what, you know, industry language, shovel-ready, but it’s really just something that’s ready to go. Mm-hmm. We already know how to do these different agricultural practices, like cover cropping, um, at a large scale, uh, rotational grazing.
Like, these are things that people have already done. These are things that actually pull from traditional ecological knowledge and indigenous stewardship practices that have been sort of reintroduced, I guess, under this, this realm of, of carbon removal. But there, there are a lot of things that we can already do.
We have substantial forest opportunity, not just here in the US, but globally. How are we thinking about different, um, forest management practices that can protect the carbon that’s already there, um, and help support store it long-term, given the fact that we know that trees are also being impacted by climate change.
They impact climate, and they are impacted by climate. So there are things that are ready to go that if we just have the funding, which we are pushing for, and if we have the, the coordination that we need, and, and what’s most important to me is, is the buy-in and the support from those that are stewarding those lands, from those that know those lands intimately, then we are ready to go with a lot of these approaches.
And I think in the interim, that’s where a lot of that research and discovery happens with maybe some of the bigger technology, uh, approaches or some of these ocean-based approaches. It’s hard to say that we should just put all our eggs in that basket. We know that land base is important. We know that there’s so many incredible co-benefits that come from forests and, and, and healthy soils outside of just that carbon.
So why not just do that? Why not just focus on it? And my response to that is, that’s not going to get us to the large amounts of carbon that we need, but it is a starting point, and I think it’s an important starting point. And I think that we should do that while we’re figuring out how best to scale up tech in a way that actually does remove carbon, that keeps the carbon where we say it’s going to keep it, and does so in a way that has true social license.
People actually want to see this, and it’s, it’s being located in places where there isn’t strong resistance or, or pushback, but actual, you know- Embracement of, of it.
[00:20:25] Corinna Bellizzi: Yeah. And I think that’s why a lot of this is happening in Iceland. There are s- Mm … swaths of land that are not really built up yet, right?
Yeah. They have laws in place that prohibit outside individuals from owning property, which keeps their property values low and stable, you know? Mm-hmm. Um, there’s… And there’s a desire to be a part of the environmental solutions- Yeah … that are afoot. They have a surplus of energy that comes from geothermal energy, so they can- That’s a big one.
Yeah, that’s a big one. They can, they can actually do the work without increasing our carbon load in the environment. Absolutely. So I think that’s really important from an experimental perspective, but also just from a governmental buy-in perspective. In fact, I know that, um, there were legislators from California that went to visit Iceland, um, to review the, um, power plant and the affiliated businesses that were near it- Yeah
um, including Vaxa. I think it w- even included, like, governor, um, the governor of California, so.
[00:21:29] Ugbaad Kosar: Governor Newsom, nice.
[00:21:30] Corinna Bellizzi: I’m, I, I’m… I think some people consider his name a four-letter word now. I’m I’m trying to avoid saying it.
[00:21:38] Ugbaad Kosar: All he said.
[00:21:40] Corinna Bellizzi: I mean, I love him to pieces. I just wish he’d say yes to Prop 40 and stop being in the billionaires’ pockets.
That’s frankly it for me. I’m, I’m, uh- Fair. I’m, I’m at a limit. I’m at my limit. Um, there are a lot of good things he’s done, too, but that one, ugh. Yeah. Anyway. You mentioned ocean-based solutions.
[00:22:00] Ugbaad Kosar: Mm-hmm.
[00:22:01] Corinna Bellizzi: I have only heard of some of these ocean-based solutions in passing, almost at cocktail parties and- Yeah
you know, at different, um, trade shows I’ve been a part of. One of which includes solidifying carbon and burying it in the ocean. Anything like that tends to scare the crap out of me. Mm-hmm. I’d like for you to, to provide your perspective on where some of these technologies are now. Yeah. How far they are along, how realistic, and if there are potential fallout from them.
Yeah. Um, like something like that, I worry about unintended consequences. Like, does the carbon get absorbed into the ocean? Does it increase the acidity of the ocean? Mm-hmm. We already know we have an acidity problem. What happens if, type thing.
[00:22:41] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. I have a long answer and I have a short answer. The short answer is I feel very uncertain, and I am really invested in just research right now of just better understanding, because there’s a lot of uncertainty when it comes to marine carbon dioxide removal.
However you wanna talk, these ocean-based approaches. Um, and then the long answer is- Again, there are, there are sort of two-ish categories of how to think about anything to do with carbon removal with the ocean. We have those, like, coastal, uh, they call them coastal blue carbon approaches when you think of, like, marshes and sea grasses.
Um, um, and just kind of… And wetlands, and just, uh, protecting and, and managing those. It’s similar to some of, like, the forest-based, um, pieces that I was talking about. Um, and there’s a ton of, especially in mangroves, there’s a ton of carbon that’s stored in, in those systems. Um, but then there’s definitely what more along the lines of what you were sharing, which is maybe further out into the ocean.
Um, there’s, like, ocean alkalinity enhancement. There’s these different, um, kelp sinking processes. There’s, there’s, there’s a, there’s a whole swath. I think it’s growing so much I can’t even keep track of just how many different ocean-based options there are. Um, but what I will say is I, I think it’s really important that we do a lot more research in there than anything else because these are open systems we’re talking about.
Mm-hmm. The ocean is just one giant o- ocean, I would say. The one giant ocean is, is just a giant open system. Um, and so at our organization, at, at Carbon180, we, we recently, um, introduced this, uh, piece of legislation called the Rescue Oceans Act, which is really just focused on strong research and development to just understand What are these impacts?
What are the, what is the potential, and what are these impacts that, that could happen if we were to move forward with ocean-based carbon removal? Um, it’s really early stage. If you were to put a timeline of, like, where the different carbon removal approaches kind of live in terms of maturity, understanding of impacts, um, scale, that sort of thing, we’ve definitely got the land-based approaches really high up there.
Um, they’re, they’re probably the most familiar. They’re the longest standing. Kind of in the middle is some of these, like, tech-based approaches I was talking about, like direct air capture, um, enhanced rock weathering, these k- types of pl- uh, options. I wanna
[00:24:55] Corinna Bellizzi: stop you for one second just to mention something I think will be- Sure
interesting to this audience if they’re not- Yeah … already aware when it comes to the land-based solutions. The land-based solutions also tend to reduce reliance on chemical pesticides and other- Yes … um, additives to the soil because they’re using cover crops that do things like fix nitrogen to the soil and benefit the plants.
They also tend to reduce the methane emissions that come off the land. So they’re both increasing soil quality, the microbiome of the soil, and they’re reducing inputs from chemical-based solutions. Absolutely. And if you’ve been paying attention to the war in Iran, then you know, too, that some of these- Mm-hmm
solutions are becoming incredibly more expensive because they tend to come from the petrochemical industry. So there are a lot of solutions in one basket when it comes to regen ag, and that is why I find much more support for it.
[00:25:50] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:25:50] Corinna Bellizzi: Um, and then I’d like to talk about the technological pieces you were referring to.
[00:25:55] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah, absolutely. I think that’s a really great addition. I think that’s, that’s incredibly important because oftentimes what leads people to be interested in some of the land-based carbon removal has nothing to do with carbon. It has everything to do with the other co-benefits that come, that are central, and they view carbon as the co-benefit.
It’s kind of like, oh, that’s, that’s a great add-on to what we were already trying to do, which was improve our bottom lines, which, and, and reducing our, our pesticides or our other inputs. Um, transitioning back towards some of these indigenous practices that have been successful for millennia. Like, tho- those are usually the things that drive people towards land based.
Um, so I think, yeah, highlighting that was, was really important. Um, the, the tech side of things, usually folks are starting with the idea of, of carbon, um, in that space, and I think part of it is because the, the very concept of it, the reason why it was created was to solve that problem. And what I experience as someone who spends my days talking to community-based organizations, environmental justice practitioners, and just viewing this from an equity and justice lens, is that there’s a lot more work to be done in actually understanding and exploring What those co-benefits are for something like direct air capture.
It’s, it’s a, it’s a less clear cut, uh, uh, a situation or example. Um, but it’s an incredibly important one, because we need to know, yes, climate is important, yes, thinking about carbon is important, but if you’re gonna place this nearby someone or nearby a community, or it’s going to… We need to really be clear about what are the community benefits that actually could come out of something like a direct air capture facility that allows us to think of not just carbon, but people in the process, um, and the planet in the process.
So it’s, it’s a less clear-cut place, and I think the ocean side of things kind of fall similar to what I would say these, like, tech, um, carbon removal approaches would look like.
[00:28:00] Corinna Bellizzi: Now, I’ve been thinking a lot about the impact of data centers. I mean, they’ve been in the news a lot.
[00:28:05] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:28:05] Corinna Bellizzi: But they also have an incredible noise pollution aspect at the same time that they’re gobbling all up a lot of energy resources and creating emissions from that as well.
Mm-hmm. The emissions that come from that are both heat and carbon related.
[00:28:21] Intro / Outro: Yeah.
[00:28:22] Corinna Bellizzi: So I wondered if you’ve had a closer look at the impact of data centers on where carbon is headed, potentially also where heat in communities and noise pollution is affected, as it might relate to some of these other solutions that could also be a bit noisy.
[00:28:38] Ugbaad Kosar: Mm-hmm. So the data centers portion for me, admittedly, is still new-ish. I’m still definitely in a place of, of learning and listening, um, and I’ve only just started really venturing into community dialogue around data centers, but I’m definitely following the news. And I can definitely see that it is, it is becoming the forefront of, of, of environmental justice, uh, in, in the US in particular, um, and I would argue in many other places.
Um, and so I think the biggest thing that I’ve taken away from- What’s been happening with the data centers conversation so far is, one, there’s a lot more alignment and, and support from people across, like, political spectrum, geography, income level when it comes to opposing a lot of these data centers, or at least demanding these, like, moratoriums of just these pauses.
Mm-hmm. Um, and a lot of it has to do with can… H- how w- how were these plans developed in the first place? Because we weren’t involved in it, right? Mm-hmm. And I think that’s a really important lesson to take away. If they were involved, if communities were involved with the planning of data centers, I think the idea of noise pollution would’ve been resolved much earlier.
Um, I think the idea of impacts to air quality and the different ways that you could configure these data centers to reduce that air quality would’ve been resolved. Um, I think water usage is, is a huge piece, and I think that would’ve been resolved. But what’s happening, what we see with data centers right now is there’s almost a reverse engineering process.
Like, people are having to stop to be like, “Oh, you all actually do care, and community voices is important, and th- this pushback is going to cause us money or time.” So let’s go back to the table and let’s try to figure out how to, how to solve this. And that’s at the best-case scenario. The worst case is that they’re, they just don’t care.
So what, what that, what I take away from that with carbon removal is, one, it’s a clear-cut more sort of recent example of why input early on at the research and development stage, which is where a lot of carbon removal technologies is at right now, is so important. Like, this is, this is… It’s not a nice-to-have.
It is an essential component to a successful climate, uh, approach, or just a project or a business proposal. Whatever you wanna call it, it is essential, and if you don’t, if you don’t take the time to pause earlier on, you may think that you’re going to the finish line quicker, but you’re just gonna be run up…
You’re just going to run up against those delays further down the line, and that pushback further down the line. So it’s been a really interesting example to follow. I think in the past I’ve leaned on looking at, like, offshore wind and a lot of the, the, the pushback and a lot of the, um, the lack of community engagement that’s happened in those spaces and, and what it had cost the offshore wind industry in the past.
But now we have this real-time example that just points people to say, “This is why equity and justice is so central.” Like, this is why it is, it is fundamental to any sort of successful anything that you can think of. Um, so it’s, it’s just been a really interesting parallel, and I think there are definitely similarities in certain aspects around some of the uncertainties, around the locations that folks wanna, um, cite.
Um, it’s often, you know, environmental justice communities that bear the brunt of a lot of these experimental projects, uh, so how do we combat that? I think there’s just a lot of similarities that I’ve been, I’ve been tracking in real time, for sure.
[00:32:15] Corinna Bellizzi: I wanna talk about the co-benefits, um, the possibility of co-benefits for communities and ecosystems when it comes to these carbon removal projects when they’re done well.
What can these carbon removal projects offer to the people and places around them?
[00:32:31] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. It’s an exciting question because I think as I’ve been sharing, it really depends on what the types of projects that we’re talking about, the places that they’re in. But I say, I say two things. I say the first is because the industry, the carbon removal industry, is still relatively nascent, I would say, compared to a lot of other climate approaches- We have an option to even define what community benefits are.
And I think it’s important to, to take a step back and have humility to know that we don’t actually know what those benefits are for different people. Everyone is going to identify something different. They’re gonna share what they want. There was this really interesting analogy I heard when I was at New York Climate Week of a person comparing going, uh, defining, like, community benefits to going to a restaurant.
And when they go and they, they order their, their dish or what have you, the, the, the restaurant messes it up, and to make it- them feel better, they bring back, uh, a dessert. The dessert is not something that anyone asked for. They… Maybe they’re allergic, they can’t even eat it. What good is it if you don’t just ask me what I want and then give me what I wanted?
Or at least let me know you couldn’t give me what I wanted, and then ask me how to make it better. So I think that’s… It’s, it’s, it’s an interesting analogy, but I think it’s an important one because I, I start with that. It’s, it’s, how do I even define what a community benefit is? I can list off what the common ones are that I hear that I can share with you, but it’s been really interesting to see just how different it shifts depending on if I’m talking to people in Texas, Louisiana, California, Washington State.
It’s very different. But I will say at a high level, um, people wanna be able to, one, have decision-making power and influence in the process. Um, that’s not necessarily a benefit, but that’s the pathway to get to those benefits. It’s not enough to just have community engagement for the sake of talking to people.
You have to have some amount of influence over what the outcome is going to be and be really clear about that in order to make people want to engage in good faith and, and gain their, their true support from start to finish. So I think that piece is really important, is just taking a reflection of what the power dynamics are and decision-making is.
Um, I think everybody, especially in this economy today, like, we need to ensure high-paying, high-quality jobs that are family sustaining, ideally that are, you know, union protected or unionized, um, uh, with safe working conditions. So any time that you can think about what that looks like Without assuming that that’s what people want, I think is incredibly important.
And also being really honest about what the benefits are. If you look at direct air capture, there’s been studies that show the different types of numbers of jobs that can happen from these really large scale plants, but a lot of them are really front-loaded to the construction-
[00:35:25] Corinna Bellizzi: Mm-hmm …
[00:35:25] Ugbaad Kosar: and less so for operation maintenance.
So we gotta be honest
[00:35:28] Corinna Bellizzi: about- It’s similar to data centers in that way. This is part of- Yeah … why I was making the analogy. I was envisioning a future in which a data center and one of these carbon capture spaces were included in the same project so that the benefits were- Yeah … greater with the use of that land.
Absolutely. You know, while also ensuring that all data centers d- all, every single data center that we approve to be built is built with a circular closed system as opposed to one that is open.
[00:35:54] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:35:54] Corinna Bellizzi: There’s a lot of bait and switch that happens. I think you mentioned the desert aspect. Yeah. That’s kind of a bait and switch.
But also we’ve seen that data centers have given plans to community to say like they were going to construct something that was more circular in design, but when it went into actual build, it became- Yep … open, which meant a lot of water use, and a lot of waste and runoff and other problems that wouldn’t have been there if the originally designed project was executed.
[00:36:21] Ugbaad Kosar: Completely agree. Um-
[00:36:23] Corinna Bellizzi: It’s just-
[00:36:24] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah … yeah. It is. That is… And I, and I think again, this, this may not be defining what a community benefit is, but it is important for the process, is transparency around what you actually can do, and be honest about what is up for discussion or what is up for uncertainty.
Like, you don’t know. I, or, or space to change in a way that’s, that’s open, and I think that’s- Mm-hmm … I think that, that doesn’t happen often because sometimes- If you, if you’re working with a, a developer or a startup that, you know, seemingly has really good intentions, there may be a fear of being fully transparent because of, of pushback or, or, or just, like, the, the idea of, like, uncertainty.
But that’s not moving in good faith. A- and, and so I think it’s important to be honest about, like, if you don’t know something, that is just as important as what you do know. Right. And, and conveying that to people. So I would say
[00:37:19] Corinna Bellizzi: that. Well, this is why the farm or land-based solutions are so much more well-accepted, because there are a lot of other benefits.
Like- Yeah … suddenly you have more butterflies in the environment. The bees aren’t suffering the same way, so you don’t have colony collapse of certain species of insects that are important for farming. Mm-hmm. You also have less runoff, and then you don’t have, um, some of these toxic pesticides entering our watershed-
[00:37:43] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah
[00:37:44] Corinna Bellizzi: including glyphosate, which is water soluble and gets in everything. It, it’s a problem. Like, these things are problems.
[00:37:51] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. But there actually- Like, you know? … has been quite a bit of, um, I wouldn’t say pushback, but maybe, like, uncertainty around some of these approaches. Like, we, we also spend a lot of time talking to farmers and ranchers, um, our land policy team especially, and I think the fear of the unknown of, of changing any one of your practices, and-
[00:38:09] Corinna Bellizzi: Mm-hmm
[00:38:09] Ugbaad Kosar: a lot of these farmers work on very, very slim margins, um, and, and oftentimes are just barely breaking even. So the idea of introducing a new amendment or a shift in your, uh, soil practices does instill, like, uncertainty and fear. And there’s
[00:38:25] Corinna Bellizzi: also the added- Well, and it takes two or three years to really start to see the benefit from it, so it’s whether they can weather that and do we have- Absolutely
funds available to support them during the transition. Absolutely. That was all part of the Green New Deal, right? Which- What happened there, Jeeves?
[00:38:41] Ugbaad Kosar: Absolutely. Yeah. There needs to be a lot of, like, upfront funding and support for those upfront costs, um, in order to support that transition. And then I also think farmer-to-farmer education is really important, um, because everyone speaks their own language, and talking about carbon and climate is not going to land with a lot of farmers.
We have to talk about, we have to talk about this in the way that they experience and their reality, and the only way to do that is through trusted conveners that they work with, which are other farmers- Yeah … other outreach supports. So it’s been, it’s been an interesting space of, it feels really obvious that there are, there are win-win-wins across the board in m- in many cases with the land base.
But influencing human behavior is incredibly, is inc- is incredibly long and, and difficult. And, and so I think, like, more effort and support in that space is, is necessary in order for this to actually be successful. And I would say similar to, to f- the forestry as well.
[00:39:30] Corinna Bellizzi: Yeah. Well, we do know that when people integrate regenerative practices fully into their farms, they’re more drought resilient.
Mm-hmm. They also are able to withstand flood more. Yep. The soil can hold more water, which means less negative impacts from it.
[00:39:45] Ugbaad Kosar: Absolutely.
[00:39:45] Corinna Bellizzi: So, uh, you know, the, the benefits are there.
[00:39:48] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah, they are. They are there, it’s just we need to do a better job of bringing the right people in the room and-
[00:39:57] Corinna Bellizzi: Yeah
[00:39:57] Ugbaad Kosar: solidifying those benefits, and promising and keeping up with that promise of those benefits.
[00:40:02] Corinna Bellizzi: Absolutely. Now I’d like to talk about building equity in from the start. Um, a recent Carbon8 180 piece says that carbon removal is coming home, and science and justice must meet it there. What does that look like on the ground?
[00:40:20] Ugbaad Kosar: That’s a great question. What does it look like on the ground? I can give you one example of what we’ve been doing. Uh, we have this re-granting program that I started at Carbon180 about five years ago, and the goal was rather than having communities have to react to all these different approaches, how do we create space for them to be proactive in, in understanding before those, those knocks on the door come?
So we ended up receiving, um, funding from, from larger philanthropy, and we re-granted all that money back out to smaller community-based organizations-
[00:40:57] Intro / Outro: Mm …
[00:40:57] Ugbaad Kosar: who, um, are interested in learning and needed the space and the capacity to do so. So what does it look like on the ground in that program? Well, we’ve done a ton of, uh, sort of 101 education on carbon removal.
Um, a lot of folks didn’t know what it was or had an inkling or kind of mixed it up with other pieces, and I think the first step to anything is knowing what you, uh, uh… You don’t know what you don’t know, so being really clear about what’s out there, what’s already happening, what are the impacts. Um, and it’s also been two-way learning, so we’ve also learned a lot from community-based organizations on what’s important to them.
What do they need to see from emerging technology? What their previous experiences have been like, and how to influence any sort of policy action or, or, uh, company engagement that we do In order to really support and center what those voices are. What’s come out of this program, which, you know, leads back to what you asked, is we’ve essentially been able to help prop up a lot of new faces that are working in the carbon removal space that come from grassroots movements, that come from community-based organizations, that have strong lived experiences, and are often the ones who are going to be directly impacted by projects that may pop up.
And they’re influencing policy, they’re, they’re helping what writing and reviewing legislation. They are sitting on the boards of different companies. Um, and they’re, they’re out there just putting out different recommendations of, of what they wanna see in the space. And it’s been an outsized impact for not just them, but for us and for the field.
Five years ago, it was very rare to find anybody who was solely focused on equity and justice in carbon removal. And now we have what I’m hoping to become this sort of self-sustaining grassroots movement of organizations that are able to support each other with their networks, um, and exchange that information, and then create their own positions and platforms on what they want to see carbon removal look like.
And it’s almost always centered on two, three things. It’s making sure that, um, there’s transparency and there’s accountability in the process. Um, um, supporting sort of meaningful engagement, and co-workshopping what those community benefits could be and putting those on the table before those companies start knocking on their doors.
[00:43:20] Corinna Bellizzi: Now, speaking to equity and justice, Carbon180 merged its science and innovation team with that work with its equity and justice. What did that change about how you do your job?
[00:43:33] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. You know, they speak a very different language. I will start there. Um, they, they, uh… And I say they, not just our science and innovation team, but I just mean the folks that they work with broadly.
They have a real, um- A different language and approach, and I think just ethos in, in how they’re thinking about these problems or how they vocalize these problems. And I think what it’s changed for me more than anything else is, one, really learning to meet people where they’re at and making sure that we are not taking for granted that we’re all speaking the same thing.
So it’s really about level setting. I think 80% of our problems, don’t quote me on that percentage, I made that up, but most of our problems are usually because we’re talking past each other. It’s not that we are actually speaking the same language and we disagree, it’s like a fundamental misunderstanding of what the other person is trying to convey.
So I think that has been truthfully life-changing for me personally in being able to, to work with them. And I think the second thing is we’ve really been able to tackle this tension that exists all the time around speed versus scale, right? A lot of, um, the folks that our science and innovation team works with is like scale, scale, scale.
We need to hit these targets. We need to hit these numbers. We need to have X amount of this done by this date. And I think for us we’re like really trying to convey that you can do that and do community participation at the same time. Yeah. You can meet those goals and merge it with people, and this is how.
Like, if you start from the beginning and you’re not working on these two parallel tracks that never intersect, then that intersection can be incredibly fruitful for the, the rest of this, not just project, but sector, I would say. So it’s been, it’s been great to be able to work with them. And, um, I think the last thing too is, is, especially for our science and innovation team, they’re incredibly thoughtful around, um, measurement and verification, which is really important.
We have to be able to do what we say we’re going to do. I think that builds trust. So if you have a project and you say it’s going to remove carbon, it needs to be able to prove that it can remove that carbon, and that that carbon is going to stay where we said it’s going to stay. So we need to be really thoughtful around what that measurement is, and where our team comes in, which is a perfect example of partnership, is and how do we convey that in a way- Yeah
that’s not hidden in data and graphs, but in a way that translates to your everyday person. Um, so that’s just one way that we’ve been, we’ve been working really closely together.
[00:46:06] Corinna Bellizzi: You know, I think you inadvertently just made the case for the need for companies to build cross-functional teams. Yes. And it’s just the way to avoid silos and poor decision-making in an organization, especially as it scales, is to ensure that you have cross-collaborative teamwork.
[00:46:25] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:46:25] Corinna Bellizzi: And, um, cross-functional teams. It’s, it’s something I’ve advocated for forever.
[00:46:30] Ugbaad Kosar: Mm-hmm.
[00:46:31] Corinna Bellizzi: It’s not easy. It sometimes, especially in the beginning, increases the length of time a project will take. Yeah. But the thing is, people get better at it the more they do it. Yeah. And so th- when you get better at it, things actually speed up and you make less mistakes.
And- Yeah … there’s less unintended consequences, so you’re just more productive and, and you have more positive output long-term when- Yeah … you spend the time in it.
[00:46:56] Ugbaad Kosar: Absolutely. I always say you don’t know what you don’t know, and I mean that so sincerely.
[00:46:59] Corinna Bellizzi: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:47:00] Ugbaad Kosar: It’s really important to talk to people outside of your circle.
[00:47:03] Corinna Bellizzi: You know, a lot of people, in business especially, are not comfortable saying they don’t know. I do not see it as a weakness. When somebody tells me they don’t know something, I’m like, “Well, what can we do to solve that?” Mm. Like, let’s just get into it together then. You don’t know the answer, how do we find the answer?
Mm-hmm. You know? Mm-hmm. Like, that is, it’s such an important part of innovation.
[00:47:25] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:47:26] Corinna Bellizzi: And too many people are afraid of it. Eh. That’s my preachy soapbox for the day.
[00:47:29] Ugbaad Kosar: Agree with you.
[00:47:31] Corinna Bellizzi: Okay. So let’s talk about what responsible carbon removal actually looks like.
[00:47:36] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:47:36] Corinna Bellizzi: Um, you launched the CORE framework in April 2026.
How would you describe it to someone who’s never heard of it?
[00:47:43] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. So- We, the, the, I will, I will start by saying it was really important for us to put forward this CORE Framework because we were experiencing what I shared earlier, which was people were using certain terms, and they were using it in incredibly different ways.
And these are important terms. We would hear Policymakers, community-based organizations, investors talk about transparency and accountability and justice and equity, and they meant wildly different things to each of these people. Of course. And so can you… No, it’s true. Yeah. And so when you think about it, imagine me being in a room and seeing how different everyone is viewing this, and trying to reconcile between the two.
It felt impossible, truthfully, and it felt like the biggest hurdle in order to actually make progress is just starting from the beginning. So we recognized that we needed these, like, working definitions of some of these incredibly important terms and, and give people real examples, tangible examples, case studies, um, tools that people could use to see what that means, like, in the real world.
Um, and that’s where the CORE framework, um, came together. The CORE stands for community and, um, informed, um, open access, reviewed and evaluated. It’s been a while since I’ve actually gone back. Um, and, and the purpose of it is it’s this living sort of, um, uh, set of resources and this framework that, um, meets people where they’re at and helps sort of explain what Carbon180 is seeing as what the underpinning to responsible carbon removal is gonna look like.
So we have some principles that kind of set the standard, things like, um, justice and account… and, and equity. Um, we n- we define, like, enforcement and what that looks like. Um, for the, the sort of mathematical side of things, the additionality, which means, like, what we’re doing is actually adding to, uh, or contributing to the, the climate crisis and not just, like, distraction.
Um, net negativity. So the, the… all these different sort of pillars, um, sort of shape what it means to be responsible when you think about carbon removal. But we tried to pair it with what we call practices, which are a- like, the, the real-world applications of some of these principles. So we talked about community benefit mechanisms.
What are ways in which we can define those? Um, knowledge building, which is so important. How are we, how are we defining who an expert is, and, and how are we, um, establishing, uh, shared knowledge, um, across different sectors and across different expertise in order to, like, essentially be able to define the same problem in the same way or a problem in a similar way.
Um, and then of course, like, workforce development. So we, we, we tried to pair them with these different examples. And then the last thing is we have a ton of case studies as well, which was particularly important. I think sometimes you just gotta hold someone’s hand through it, um, to be able to really understand what it is we’re trying.
So we tried to pull from different, different readiness levels, um, different actors, and just kind of walk you through from start to finish, if you were to apply CORE, here’s what it would look like for, for your project.
[00:51:00] Corinna Bellizzi: Now, transparency and accountability are guiding principles of this core framework.
[00:51:06] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:51:06] Corinna Bellizzi: What does that mean for a neighbor who wants to know what is happening on a site nearby?
[00:51:11] Ugbaad Kosar: It means they’re able to get that information, uh, openly and transparently. I shouldn’t say transparently, that’s the definition. Um, that they’re able to get it, um, openly and readily, and that it’s not hidden under, um, intellectual, uh, property or, or, um, uh, sort of buried under, uh, these really complicated spreadsheets that are linked under this, you know- Mm
website that no one knows exists. It needs to be something that is readily available to that person. Um, and there are a lot of different ways that you can do that. Um, there are a lot of different ways that we’ve thought about doing it, whether it’s employing your, um… Or bringing in your local government to host some of that information, making sure those companies are regularly reaching out to, to residents and letting them know where to get that information and, and making it obvious.
Um, but it just makes sure that everyone is really aware of, like, how these decisions are being made. Um, and it really ensures that, um, any sort of data that’s collected is, is, is shared. Um, ’cause that’s, that’s everyone’s data, and I think it’s important for them to be able to… That community member to be able to know what’s, what’s happening in real time.
[00:52:20] Corinna Bellizzi: Well, I love that. Frankly, I’ve heard it described in the natural products industry, like, it’s as simple as a company revealing their sources and then having the certificate of analysis that has the actual test results a, a click away. Like, you don’t have to send an email to someone to request it, it’s just right there.
[00:52:36] Ugbaad Kosar: Yes, exactly.
[00:52:37] Corinna Bellizzi: And I think that’s really what it comes down to. I think many companies talk about transparency as if it’s that simple, and it often isn’t.
[00:52:44] Ugbaad Kosar: Mm-hmm.
[00:52:45] Corinna Bellizzi: So making it that easy and digestible is important.
[00:52:48] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. I couldn’t agree more.
[00:52:51] Corinna Bellizzi: Yeah. As we prepare to wrap the episode and really bring it home for people, I wanna talk about what people listening today might be able to do.
Mm-hmm. So if they want to support responsible carbon removal in their communities, where would you invite them to begin?
[00:53:09] Ugbaad Kosar: I mean, first just getting familiar with what carbon removal is, um, and making sure that folks are, are aware of all the different ways it can show up. Um, I think it can surprise people of, of just how small or large a carbon removal project could be.
Um, so I would say that’s the, the first place. Um, I would love to invite folks to check out our website. I think we’ve got a ton of really great resources, and just showing folks, um, where, um, or, or how, like, the different stages are at for different, um, carbon removal projects. Um, and then I think thirdly, the…
It’s, it’s incredibly important to touch in with, um… I know community-based organizations in particular play a really important role for helping to not only influence, but also advocate for, uh, communities that they, that they’re, um, in. And I would honestly recommend reaching out to those local community-based organizations to get curious of what they already know, but also make sure that if they’re, if, if it’s not on their radar and you’re interested, that they get it on their radar.
Mm-hmm. And that it is something that they’re, they’re tracking, and, and just get plugged in in, in that way. Those are a couple sort of lower lift ways, I think, that could, that can support someone getting familiar with the space.
[00:54:19] Corinna Bellizzi: And what do you think an individual can do if they learn that a project is proposed in their community, whether or not they automatically support it?
[00:54:27] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah. There should be some level of public engagement that’s happening. Um, even if it’s just being, the bare minimum being regulated by law. Um, I would get connected with your, your local government, um, and get a better understanding of have, have, have there already been hearings that have existed that you didn’t know about?
Um, or how, like, what is, what is up and coming? Um, I think that’s another important piece. Um, and I think the last piece, not to shamelessly plug us again, but we are trying to put together some, some toolkits for folks on how to get engaged with these topics at your local town halls. Um, and, and what are some of the common questions that might come up, and where to get those resources.
‘Cause it’s gonna be really important for, for folks to arm themselves with the, the data and information they need so that they can actually, I wouldn’t say just push back, but just get curious, um- Mm-hmm … in settings. Uh, so I, I think those are a couple of the places that I would start with.
[00:55:20] Corinna Bellizzi: Fantastic. I have one last question.
[00:55:22] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah.
[00:55:23] Corinna Bellizzi: What gives you hope about where this field in particular is headed? And any closing thoughts you have you could share now.
[00:55:30] Ugbaad Kosar: Yeah, absolutely. You know, I’ve been in this space intently for about eight years now, and I can’t even begin to explain how much it’s shifted just in those eight years in terms of the emphasis that’s being put on for equity and justice, and the care that a lot more people are putting into thinking about the impacts on communities and thinking about impacts on the planet.
And I, it, it’s exciting. It’s exciting to me that I see that this is something that needs to happen. I see that carbon removal is essential. And I’m also starting to see a shift, however small, that people care about people, and people want to do this right. So I think marrying those two is, is what really gives me a lot of hope.
I, I do see a pathway forward where we’re able to get this done right. We’re still early enough that we don’t have to repeat the same mistakes that have happened with previous efforts, and we can learn from that. And I think we can, we can create the world that we want to see if we are just, you know, working together, um, and we’re centering, uh, those, those communities and those environmental justice communities in particular that are often bearing the brunt but are rarely involved in, in the problem-solving process of it all.
[00:56:43] Corinna Bellizzi: Wow. Well, thank you for joining me today, for insisting that the way we build climate solutions matters as much as whether we build them, and for working to make sure that communities have a voice from the beginning. I personally have loved this interview, and I hope that you’ll come on again soon. I will of course include links and show notes to carbon180.org, and also to where you’re socially active.
I so appreciate you and what you do. If you need me, I’m here.
[00:57:14] Ugbaad Kosar: Thank you. It was such a pleasure. Hope you have a great day.
[00:57:16] Corinna Bellizzi: Before we go, I want to share a quick word about this show’s cause partner, Prescott College. This is a college celebrating its 60th anniversary. It’s where I earned my PhD in sustainability, and I’m happy to say I have officially finished all that work with all the requirements.
I have that degree. Prescott prepares people to lead regenerative change alongside the communities they serve, which is a lot like what Ugonna described today. If you can, please join me with a monthly gift of even $60 at caremorebebetter.com/support. The link is in our show notes. Thank you listeners now and always for being a part of this pod and this community, because together we can change the future of how we handle carbon, bring more life down to planet Earth, improve the air and the water in our atmospheres, and have a future for our children that we can all be proud of.
Thank you.
[00:58:16] Intro / Outro: Thanks for listening to Care More, Be Better, a podcast for social good. To make sure you never miss an episode, subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen to podcasts, and share with your friends to help us reach more people and spread more social good.
Author
-
View all posts
Corinna is a natural products industry executive who has earned a reputation for leading the development and growth of responsible brands (e.g. Nordic Naturals, iwi, NutriGold). In her professional life, she champions social benefit programs to enhance company impact while preserving and protecting our home planet. She’s presently working tirelessly on the development of a new pre-market that seeks to achieve a carbon-negative impact. In January 2021 she launched her show, Care More, Be Better: A Social Impact + Sustainability Podcast to amplify the efforts of inspired individuals and conscious companies. Through Care More Be Better, she shares their stories in an effort to show us all that one person with one idea can have a big impact. As part of her lifelong education journey, she earned her MBA from Santa Clara University, graduating at the top of her class with a triple focus in Entrepreneurship, Leadership and Marketing in June 2021.