Watch the Episode here
Listen to the Podcast here
For decades, large corporations have privatized their massive profits while quietly shifting environmental, social, and health costs onto the public. Unpacking these systemic costs is central to the discussion in The Profiteers, which diagnoses how business practices impact society at large. In this episode, host Corinna Bellizzi speaks with Christopher Marquis, Professor of Chinese Management at the University of Cambridge Judge Business School and author of Better Business, to analyze the hidden mechanics of corporate externalities. From plastics lobbying and regulatory co-optation to visionary models of regenerative agriculture and foundation ownership, they explore why exposing systemic corporate abuse is the first crucial step toward real reform. Discover how innovative enterprise models, policy levers, and conscious consumer choices can help build a truly sustainable and regenerative economy.
About Christopher Marquis

Professor Marquis’ research and teaching focus on how some of the biggest crises of our day – including climate change, inequality, and discrimination – are intimately connected to how our current economic and societal systems prioritize accumulating and concentrating wealth for the few over the concerns and needs of everyone and everything else. His research and writing focus on the need to rebalance the interactions between corporations, governments, and civil society to deliver socially and environmentally beneficial outcomes to all.
Marquis is the author of The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profits and Socialize Costs. His earlier books include the award-winning Better Business: How the B Corp Movement is Remaking Capitalism and Mao and Markets: The Communist Roots of Chinese Enterprise, which was a Financial Times Best Book of 2022. He has also authored more than 20 peer-reviewed academic articles and more than 50 Harvard business cases on topics related to social innovation, sustainable business and doing business in China.
Professor Marquis served 2 terms as an Associate Editor at Administrative Science Quarterly and has also been a Senior Editor at Organization Science and Management and Organization Review. He has also served a term as Representative at Large for the International Association for Chinese Management Research (IACMR) and Organization and Management Theory Division, Academy of Management.
Before returning to academia, Marquis was a Vice President and Technology Manager at JP Morgan Chase. He currently is on the sustainability advisory board of the French multinational Sanofi Consumer Healthcare.
Guest Website: https://chrismarquis.com
Guest LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/christopher-marquis-3884834/
Guest X: https://x.com/Chris_Marquis_
Guest Substack: https://substack.com/@chrismarquis
Resources Mentioned:
BOOK: The Profiteers
BOOK: Better Business
Show Notes:
- 00:00 Who Really Pays For Corporate Externalities?
- 05:35 The Plastic Dilemma: Rethinking Packaging In Sustainable Business
- 10:03 Privatizing Profits & Socializing Costs: Unpacking Corporate Externalities
- 18:06 Lessons From GE: How Shareholder Primacy Distorts Business Ethics
- 27:10 Big Tech And Algorithms: Profit Growth Vs. Corporate Accountability
- 33:02 Unpacking The Policy Debate: Plastic Lobbying & Chemical Recycling
- 40:30 Rethinking Lifecycles: Circularity And Extended Consumer Responsibility
- 47:33 Regenerative Agriculture: How Purpose-Driven Brands Restore Soil & Systems
- 55:23 Building A Regenerative Economy: Purpose-Driven Governance & Ownership
- 01:01:34 Conclusion & Takeaways: Empowering Individual Action and Policy Reform
BUILD A GREENER FUTURE with CARE MORE BE BETTER
Together, we planted 36,044 trees in 2025 through our partnership with ForestPlanet. We screamed past our goal of planting 20,000 trees thanks to subscribers like you!
CAUSE PARTNER
If you value open dialogue, sustainability, and social equity, I invite you to support our new cause partner — Prescott College. To learn more about this effort and to support the show, visit: https://caremorebebetter.com/support/
Follow us on social media:
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/caremorebebetter
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@caremorebebetter
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/caremorebebetter
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/CareMoreBeBetter
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/care-more-be-better
—
How Corporations Socialize Costs In The Profiteers With Christopher Marquis
Who Really Pays For Corporate Externalities?
Each week, we explore the intersection of sustainability, justice, and regenerative thinking to build a better future for people and the planet. A few years ago, I had Christopher Marquis on the show to talk about his book, Better Business: How the B Corp Movement is Remaking Capitalism. This is specifically about the rise of the B-corp movement, and I have my copy here. He’s back to discuss his newer book, The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profit and Socializes Cost. This book asks an even harder question. Not how good companies get better, but who actually pays when companies cut corners?
Who pays for those externalities? Christopher Marquis is a senior professor of Chinese management at the University of Cambridge Judge Business School. His most recent book, The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profits and Socializes Costs, argues that corporations have spent decades quietly shifting the true cost of their business from pollution to labor, exploitation, and environmental damage onto us, shifting those costs onto the public while keeping the profits for themselves. You could call this the socialization of business. With that, I hope you’ll join me in welcoming him back to the show.
—
Thank you so much for joining me, Chris.
Great to be with you, Karina. Thanks so much.
Now, your book from Better Business: How The B Corp Movement is Remaking Capitalism to now The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profit and Socializes Cost really is still fundamentally hopeful, as bleak as some of these stories can be. I wonder if you could tell us a little bit about what made you write this second book about the companies that are doing it wrong.
I appreciate you noticing that it actually is optimistic, even though the title is pretty pessimistic and there are a lot of pretty negative examples in there. Some of the other folks, many people have told me the book was hard to get through. I do not think that it was because it was necessarily thought to be poorly written, just because it was a lot of negative stuff, particularly upfront. It seems you must have made it to the end if you got to the hopeful part.
I think, too, it’s identifying the problem. You have to identify the problem to be able to solve it. That’s what you’re getting at, right?

Exactly. I really appreciate you noticing that. The genesis of this book came from two different places. One, when I was trying to publish Better Business, and this Better Business was published in 2020. This is probably like, I’m not sure, 2017, 2018, or so. One of the publishers I talked to said, “Your book is too good. Good things do not sell. We need something bad.” At the time, there was a book, Bad Blood, which is about Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos. They pointed out that this is the book that actually sells.
What they said is that, actually, within your diagnosis, which is a small part of Better Business, there are a lot of reasons why companies are abusing the system that need B-Corps, that need sustainable business. They really recommended that I focus more on the negative aspects. That was like one motivation. Again, it is about diagnosing the problems with the broader system, and why reform, sustainability at the company level, at the policy level, I think is really important too. Also, us all as individuals. That was one motivation.
The second was the inspiration from so many of the companies that I had been talking to as a result of writing Better Business. One that really stands out and was really influential was a company called Grove Collaborative, which is in the Bay Area in the US, and they market a variety of home goods and types of products. Soaps and cleaning fluids, etc. Those types of products are liquids. Traditionally, they would need a plastic container.
The co-founder, Stu Landsberg, said to me once when I was talking to him, he said, “The Responsibility Growth Collaborative, what I think about is what is the biggest area of damage that we do and that is where I should be focusing my attention, not some random, volunteering program or other maybe more minor sustainability program, but like, what is the core issue?” For them, it was plastic. They set off on this path of becoming Zero Plastic, which, for their product category, is really, really hard, potentially virtually impossible. What this allowed them to do was actually see a lot of innovations. Let’s say we’re talking about shampoo.
If you want to have a shampoo that is not in a plastic bottle, liquid shampoo, well, actually, you can redesign the product as a bar, and then you can package it in cardboard or paper. That’s one of the things they did. Actually, it turns out that they’ve won a bunch of awards for their bar shampoos. A variety of other innovations, from even having a P&L devoted to plastic that they can then assess general managers on. It’s innovations like this where companies are saying, “What’s the externality that’s associated with my business? How can I be responsible and sustainable through innovation, through new business processes, etc?”
The Plastic Dilemma: Rethinking Packaging In Sustainable Business
Man, you’re speaking to my heart. One of the things I just shared before we hopped on this call is I just completed my dissertation, all the requirements of my PhD at Prescott College.
Congratulations. That’s a big accomplishment.

It’s a lot of work, right? Writing it out in dissertation format took me a lot longer than I anticipated. It has given me a whole new appreciation for the process of publishing your books. The thing I’m drawn to in this whole conversation about plastics is that it is hard. I’ve been on the manufacturing side as well. As you’re bringing to market things like creams and lotions and things along these lines, it can be incredibly difficult.
One of the brands I chose to assess when I was diving into what it takes to build a regenerative company for my dissertation was this company out of New Zealand called the Organic Skin Co. They’re down to only two percent of their packaging material is now plastic. It’s essentially just the cap that goes on the end of a tube. The leader had to be truly uncompromising in order to get there. They had to commit. They had to go headlong and just say, “I’m doing it better. It’s going to be wood. It’s going to be glass. It’s going to be aluminum. It’s not going to be plastic.”
Making that choice is hard, especially when you’re trying to bring a product to market that is somewhat prestigious and that you want to command respect on the shelf. Even how you construct a box, what it looks like, really matters, especially in the beauty space. What they’ve done is really disrupt that marketplace. They are really the few. You mentioned the Grove Collective. They are the few. I’ve interviewed in the past somebody who made shampoo bars and conditioner bars. I’ve used those products, and I have to tell you, they’re still my favorite. It’s not in a bar form.
What do I do? As a greenie who’s sitting here wearing a shirt I got it goodwill and who likes to make things last and be durable and all those things. Much of this whole challenge keeps getting pushed back onto consumers. You mentioned regulators like, we just have to choose better. We have to go to the bar. We have to do this. Maybe that’s not the way in which we want to care for our hair.
We want something that’s going to be in a cream. Why cannot we demand better from that regulatory perspective and push things in a direction where either these packaging items are fully reusable, and there’s some program to get them refilled, or that the externalities are really put back on the corporation so they come up with better solutions globally? What are your thoughts along that, and how do we get to that space?
I totally agree with you. I teach at a business school. I study business. I write about business. A lot of times, people misinterpret, maybe think of a bias that everything needs to be through private sector solutions or some voluntary framework or some collective action, all of which are important. In some ways, my implicit theory of change is that it’s not an either-or. I think the private sector and public sector need to work closely together. What the private sector has is innovation. It can test business models. It can show how things work, which then, through collective action, can actually become part of policy.
The private sector and public sector need to be working closely together. The private sector has innovation and can test business models, with the goal of having them made into something mandatory.
We have examples of this. For instance, from my B-Corp book, some of the assessment criteria ended up making their way into some of the European regulations. The benefit corporation form is now spreading around the world. I was really happy. I recently read a really good book that I recommend, called Incorruptible by Eric Ries. He actually also mentions this idea that the private sector is where a lot of new ideas, innovations around sustainability, mission, and purpose can be tested, with the goal of having them made into something more mandatory.
Privatizing Profits & Socializing Costs: Unpacking Corporate Externalities
Let’s talk about the privatization of profits and socializing costs. Can you explain what that phrase actually means to people who might not be familiar with the term socialize costs?
It sounds complicated, actually. As you mentioned, it was intended to be a relatively straightforward way of describing the idea of externalities, which you also mentioned in your intro.
People outside of the business world do not know what that means, right?
This is a concept that I think people probably intuitively understand, although it has this very abstract type of word, externalities. The easiest example is carbon emissions, which are in the news a lot. Now there are all these things like wildfires, heat problems, and lots of issues. A factory, let’s say, is expelling pollutants into the air. It’s not charged at all for the damage that it’s doing to the climate. Probably the place around, the communities around the factory, maybe some of the people have higher healthcare costs because they might have some respiratory or other issues.
Those are examples of where the company probably should have. There could be a tax, or some other mechanism to actually incorporate that cost. Damage to the earth, damage to the community, and damage to individuals’ health are the social costs. It’s things that are leading to higher profit for companies that actually probably should be, or that are costs that they’re putting off on society and the environment. One of the reasons I wrote the book is because of a lot of the creative things I’ve seen businesses do, like Grove Collaborative, that I mentioned, and I wanted to put forward a lot of those thoughtful solutions.
Also, this is traditionally an economics concept. When your economists are always thinking about either pricing or market mechanisms, and certainly things like carbon prices or carbon markets are important, I’m not saying that those are not important. What is missed if you just take a narrow economic lens is the fact that the large, self-interested companies are actually, in some ways, through their political action, through their communication strategies, aiming to transfer those costs onto us in very sneaky types of ways. A lot of the things I do in the book are to try to identify some of those communication and lobbying standards.
Large, self-interested companies are, through their political action and communication strategies, aiming to transfer their costs onto us in very sneaky ways.
We’re just talking about plastic. There’s a lot of work around the world on extended producer responsibility for plastic. It turns out a lot of that in the US is actually deeply co-opted by the packaging industry, by the beverage industry. Here’s an externality that we see, and it looks like we’re going to have a public sector solution. Actually, it gets weakened in systematic ways through lobbying and other influence tactics. There are a lot of industry associations whose main goal is just to weaken those kinds of regulations. The other thing I’ll mention is that there’s a big PR and communication effort as well.
One of the most famous examples that relates to carbon emissions is around BP, how they were very active in pushing this idea of individual carbon footprints. You know, and we’re all so busy thinking about like, “I should not fly, or we’re shaming people for flying, or I have to be vegan, and I’m vegan, and I fly more than I should certainly, I tried to try to reduce it. I try to do my best.” I have this guilt, and we are all thinking because of all these communication strategies of BP and other fossil fuel companies, when literally 70% of the carbon emissions for the past 25, 30 years are from 100 companies.
Instead of everyone feeling guilty about flying, let me focus on those 100 companies and actually control them. You’ve seen the massive amounts of profiteering following, first, the invasion of Ukraine, now the Iran war, where there have been fuel price spikes around the world. Those have been taken as opportunities for these companies to earn more money than ever. This is what we should be focused on, not worrying about us. We should all do our best. I’m not saying that we should not be climate-conscious in our daily actions. The big deal is what these under companies are doing.
I want to underline that by saying something that I think we all need to talk more about when it comes to personal accountability, because that’s not to say you should not recycle, and you should not care about the things that you buy, and maybe work with more natural fibers, or if you want something used, try to generate less waste, generally speaking.

Even if you were perfect, let’s say you were vegan and you only sourced food from within 100 miles of your door and you only bicycled or walked and you were on full solar power and regenerative solutions in your own home, living fully vegan and plastic free, the difference you would make is akin to a rounding error with nine zeros in front of it and a three, so 0.00003% for our global problem. That’s doing everything right.
People who believe in incrementalism will often say, “If you get all the meat-eaters to just eat meat once a day or no animal products before five,” like Jonathan Safran Foer likes to say. That can help. That might help more than the individuals who are out there being militant and really working to make the minimal footprint that they can.
The problem is bigger. One of the things I was hoping you would bring up when it comes to these socialized costs is also things like the tax credits that these companies are getting and the incentives that we put in place. Basically, they’re not paying for the infrastructure that they’re slurping from. They’re not paying for the water or the electricity. The AI data center is a key example. What do we do about these things?
I know. It’s really stark in, like, the agricultural realm and others as well. Many things are subsidized. The wrong things, in some ways, are subsidized. People are always saying that sustainable things are so expensive. Maybe they’re more expensive because the unsustainable items are actually subsidized.
Corn and soy, that are in everything.
Exactly. It’s really frustrating, where I think the knee-jerk reaction is always around. It’s a luxury item, Patagucci and all these things. Those complaints about sometimes sustainable products being more luxury items, I mean, I think it’s a valid thing for people to say. It’s not even a playing field that we’re dealing with, where so much of the conventional, which is unsustainable, so to speak, is being supported by the government.
Lessons From GE: How Shareholder Primacy Distorts Business Ethics
You opened the book with the story of GE and the Hudson River. Why did you do that? That moment obviously stayed with you for a long time. I’d like you to share about that.
I encourage people who are tuning in to read the book. Let me tell you what I hope. I’ve been studying sustainability for twenty-some years now. It’s been a while. I often wonder, like, what got me started? When I was originally doing these studies and teaching, it was pretty rare. One thing I kept thinking about, in part, I think it might have been because I was a caddy for ten years at a country club carrying bags around. Part of the story has to do with golf.
That made me think, anyway, I attended when I was a doctoral student at the University of Michigan, a talk by Jack Welch, the former CEO of General Electric, known as the best CEO of the 20th century. It’s so interesting how all these things intersect. He was actually interviewed by this guy, Stuart Varney, who at the time was at PBS. Actually, the interview ended up being shown on PBS. People can see it on YouTube if they want. This guy, Stuart Varney, he’s from the UK.
I know that when I always show up at places now as a Cambridge professor, people are expecting this very sophisticated English accent. He’s someone that has, I think his sophisticated English accent has taken him probably further than he belongs to, belongs to God, he’s now a big Fox News commentator. Anyway, so it’s not necessarily politically neutral, I guess, is my point. Anyways, he asked Jack Welch all these very softball questions.
When the students got a chance to ask a question, the hard questions came up. Two that I recall. One was in regard to the time GE had just settled longstanding lawsuits around the Hudson River, where they had been knowingly polluting and putting toxic chemicals like PCBs into the river. They ended up coming to an agreement where they were limited to a certain amount, and the student challenged, “Shouldn’t your responsibility be to bring it back to normal? Why should it be like this, a certain low amount?” He basically ranted at this person that they were unrealistic and that business needs to have a wider berth.
Think about the fact that putting PCBs in a river is really extreme. Also, all this misinformation presaged, I guess, a lot of the misinformation environment today and just bald-faced lies about PCBs not being carcinogenic and various things. When you’re a PhD student, do not engage with these supposedly best CEOs of the century. This is one thing that really stuck out to me. The other thing that stuck out was stuck out at me. It’s amazing that this existed not that long ago. Another student challenged him on the selection of his successor, which ended up being a guy named Jeffrey Immelt. It was down to three people, blanking.
I do not know their exact names, but one of them went to work at 3M. Another went to work at Home Depot. Once they were not selected, it basically ended up destroying those companies, interestingly enough. It was three White men. They did a lot of the selection process at these golf resorts, like Augusta National, which is where the most famous Masters tournament is played. Up until that point, that was like 2004 or so, literally, like women were excluded from belonging. People of color were excluded from belonging. The student was like, “Aren’t you basically stacking the deck against these other groups if you’re part of the selection process in these exclusionary environments?” His response, again, was, “That’s business. That’s just the way things are.”
I can almost imagine that they’re having a two-martini lunch while they’re doing these interviews, you know?
Exactly. Anyway, those things really stuck with me, and I think they underline a lot of the themes that I’ve ended up researching.
I find it very interesting. That’s the entire backstory for that because you, especially as you’re in business school, certain leaders are held up almost as if they’re gods, right?
Jack Welch for the longest time.
Jack Welch for a very long time, and then the founders of Apple computers, a key example.
Founders of Tesla, SpaceX, Meta, and Amazon. It’s really egregious how some of the people who are having the most destruction, in my opinion, in the world end up being lionized as these amazing leaders.
It’s really egregious how some of the people that are having the most destruction in the world end up being lionized as these amazing leaders.
When you look at what they lobby against, I think I just saw on the news that Facebook has been ordered to pay a billion dollars specifically because of the harm to children that their social platforms have generated. My first thought when I saw that was, how is that actually going to improve things, and who is the money going to? We all know that social media and this bite-sized economy of consumption of media are actually making us less critical in our thinking. It’s slowing down kids’ reading and comprehension. We’re distracting people into maybe obedience. That really might be what’s happening here. I just think these big tech oligarchs, we do not hold them accountable enough. If paying a fine is all they have to do, then what does it really change?
It’s always these excuses they have. There’s a book, I’m blanking on the title of it, by the person who was the head of public affairs and government affairs at Meta. Careless People is what it was called. It was really an inside expose of Facebook and really basically how morally corrupt and arguably evil Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg are and have no moral compass. It’s all just about more growth, more growth. It was so interesting to read about.
You might remember when Google, Facebook, and all these companies were relatively early. People did not know how they were going to monetize. It was like, these companies, I’m not sure, they seem to be providing a good service, but how are they going to make money, basically? They came up with these advertising models, which are micro-targeted, and it was an incredibly challenging and sophisticated set of infrastructure that needed to be created in order to do that.

They did that. That is apparently very hard. When you hear about like one of the things Facebook has also been, I think both legally sanctioned for and fined a reasonable amount is in regards to like teenage girls and the extent to which they’re like queuing all these bad behaviors for them and like intentionally trying to create bad body image in these very forget exactly what all the things that got found for, but their excuse is it’s just too hard to be able to figure all that out.
Internal memos show that they actually are doing the opposite. They’re actually engineering the way the media is presented in order to enhance those issues because they create greater engagement. Also, they did this other thing that was going to make them more money. They’re willing to overcome all the challenges to make money, but actually do something more ethical. It’s like, “That’s too hard,” which I find to be pretty unacceptable.
Companies are willing to overcome all the challenges to make money, but actually doing something more ethical gets written off as ‘too hard.’
Big Tech And Algorithms: Profit Growth Vs. Corporate Accountability
They blame the algorithms. “It’s just the way the algorithm is performing or whatever.” It’s like, who created the algorithm? If you let it out of the box and it’s doing its own improvements now, then who’s liable? You’re still the company that is running these things. I want to get back to talking a bit about the plastic problem because it is tied to everything in the petrochemical world as well. Carbon, land, the bigger picture of these externalized costs. We can look at who pays for carbon emissions. We can look at who pays for damage in specific areas or encourage companies to go in these directions. Is there a common playbook that shows up across the different cases that you looked at?
Who’s paying for the plastic issue? Yes.
If they’re working, how are they working to bring these things together? Any creative ideas you’re seeing?
It’s a big challenge because you have the packaging industry. It is a very powerful lobby. I criticize a lot of companies and various industries for their culpability in these problems. In only two instances have I had, in some ways, attacks from industry actors, one of which is the plastics industry. I posted something online, yes, related to the book. They sent me all these emails and veiled threats and then other carrot-type things about giving me access to X, Y, and Z. A big challenge is that you have these very powerful incumbents that really police. I’m like a minor at a high-status university, I guess, but come on. My social media voice is not as big that they should be. They should feel so threatened that they threaten me.
They’re mad about your Substack. Is that what you’re saying?
Yes, basically.
I will include a link to your Substack. I really recommend everybody subscribe because you produce incredible content that really keeps me apprised of what’s new in research media too, which I really appreciate.
Thanks. Anyway, so you have these big incumbents that are out there watching and policing. It’s also really hard without a lot of research to actually know what is right, so to speak. Two issues that I think are really important that I do not fully understand. At one point when I was writing the book, I might have understood it now, but it’s now that’s a couple of years ago, and I’ve given how long it takes to publish books. I do not recall, but one is this EPR, where they get hijacked by companies. It looks good on the surface. We have the extended producer responsibility, and companies are going to be taxed.
EPR laws, what are they? Environmental protection laws, is that what you’re referring to?
No, extended producer responsibility. Companies that have some tax, so to speak, on these companies that then go into recycling infrastructure or some other program. It’s a way to try to pay for the externality. Two things. One, the phase-in period is very long. One of them is like ten years, basically. They passed a number of US states, maybe five. Maine has one. I know New York for a while and was thinking about one. I do not know if it ever passed. California has one. One is actually, if these EPR rules are actually getting at the current issue, one person I’ve learned a lot from on this is a former Obama administration official in the EPA named Judith Enck.
Yes, we had her on the show in episode 261 about her book.
She runs this organization, Beyond Plastics. Actually, it was my interview with her that ended up triggering a lot of the plastic that got me on the radar of the plastic industry lobbying group. I highly recommend her book or her work because it’s thoughtful, rigorous, and has the public interest at the core, not necessarily the industry. She’s willing to take on the industry as well. EPR, and I think about the types of recycling.
There’s a lot of discussion of advanced, so-called advanced recycling, which is a chemical process that breaks down plastic. Apparently, it’s not like regular plastic recycling ends up being that you have to do it when it’s chemical. Because of the impurities and different colors, you actually end up not being able to have the recycled plastic go into a use that is equivalent to what it comes from. Usually, it’s downcycling. This so-called advanced recycling.
Milk cartons become playground-like bricks and things like that.
Advanced recycling, the industry talks a lot about because it actually separates out the chemical components, and I guess you can put them back together, but also it’s very polluting, which is the problem and the extent. People should check Judith’s work to get a clear and up-to-date assessment of that. It’s very challenging because there is all this misinformation.
Unpacking The Policy Debate: Plastic Lobbying & Chemical Recycling
It’s very scientific too. If somebody on the chemistry side has done a ton of reading, I had this challenge. I interviewed this guy, Chris DeArmitt, who Judith Enck cannot stand, when I expressed that I would be interviewing him because he was essentially trying to make the case that the plastic problem is not as bad as we have all been led to believe. Now, the problem with talking to him is that he’s very deeply steeped in chemistry, and he’s done a ton of reading. When I’m interviewing him, I’m not a chemist.
I’m not really suited to be able to hold his feet to the fire in the same way another chemist might be. I have not read all the articles that he’s read about the pollution, and he starts talking about the particles per trillion and whether it’s really producing these negative health effects and whether it’s really impacting the environment. We’ve just overexaggerated the challenges.
Also, during the entire interview is love bombing me, like saying things along the lines of, “You’re asking all these really interesting questions. I am so thankful that you’re willing to have these conversations. Often, people on the other side of the aisle, they’re not even willing to look at it.” I’m just like, “The love bombing is a manipulation tactic that is often used by people on opposing sides to try and tell their story.”
I just kept going back to this, like, “How is this guy compensated? Is somebody on the chemical side of the industry paying him? Is he in the pocket of somebody?” He claimed he was not, but how do you prove it? At the end of the day, I just decided not to release that episode. It is one of only two episodes in the entirety of my recording. I’m up to almost 300 episodes now that I have not released because I just thought it was dangerous.
It’s good that you tried to talk to him. This is something, and this is why I teach at business schools. It’s really important to engage and try to understand that in today’s day and age, given polarization and how social media really results in all of us being in our own little bubbles that just reinforce our ideas. It’s so important to try to actually have those conversations. It’s a shame that it ended up going the way it did, so you were not able to release it because I think it’s really important.
I just felt like it was too manipulated. At the end of the day, if I didn’t feel confident in my ability to hold his feet to the fire because I was not as informed as I would need to be in order to do that, then it’s just a disservice to the audience because they might come away feeling more skeptical about how big this plastic problem is. Should I really be worried about clothing my children in plastic clothing? There are numerous reasons to worry about that. One of which is that if you have an open fire in your home for any reason, stuff will melt onto your skin.
Microplastics.
How is it not concerning that you eat a fish from the ocean or lake now, and you’re consuming a bunch of microplastics? They can actually be teased out from the flesh and seen with the naked eye and under a microscope. All the different colors and everything else.
It’s very hard to know.
Endocrine disruption. There are all sorts of things. We are experiencing more and more health challenges than prior generations, where I’m looking at my mother-in-law, who’s 90, and how she eats iceberg lettuce and deli meats and all this stuff. I’m like, “If I ate that way, there’s no way I’d be able to live to 90.” We’re dealing with the barrage of all the pollutants that we accumulate throughout our lives now, which is so much greater than in prior generations. That’s something we do not talk about enough.
You’re right. There’s a huge health aspect to the sustainability and responsibility story that I think is connected as much as it should be.
I have concerns about us relying on our lawmakers to solve some of these problems, especially now. Going back to my conversation with Judith Enck and your conversation with her. Was there something specific that her work helped reveal to you about these special interests that are quietly rewriting a lot of our laws and these profit-seeking industries?
What was really helpful was how she was able to actually connect the dots in a detailed way. That’s my suspicion, but as you mentioned, chemistry is obviously complicated. Policymaking is really complicated too. You have these documents that are hundreds of pages, and you have these competing narratives, and she’s able to actually walk you through the law or intended laws in ways where you can see where that corporate interest is. That deep knowledge in a subject area would be able to communicate like that is hugely valuable.
You have to know quite a bit to be able to do so. I feel like Judith does a good job in her book.
Totally. I read about The Profiteers before her book. I really, in some ways, boned up on all these things when I was writing the chapter on plastics. Also, I’m studying so many things right now. The details of it are not as deep anymore. It’s tough to stay on top of everything.
That book is The Problem with Plastic by Judith Enck. She also went through the trouble of ensuring that the book itself would be manufactured with zero plastics. That is apparently something that is hard to do because even in the jackets, there’ll be like a laminate layer or something to that effect. The book is plastic-free, or you can also get a digital copy. That’s how I tend to read most of my books these days because it takes up less space on my shelves. They’re already completely full. That’s why they’re covered with curtains.
I thought that might be windows out there, but those are shelves.
No, stacked books. I know that we can talk about things like recycling. You mentioned chemical recycling, which is supposed to make plastic like virgin plastic so it can be reused. The chemicals that result from it are a problem. That’s an externality that needs to be handled. Now, we also know that recycling is generally a band-aid, and moving more toward reuse or more durable or natural materials is honestly the better way to go. Are you seeing anything really interesting that you came across in your research that you think deserves some more attention?
Rethinking Lifecycles: Circularity And Extended Consumer Responsibility
People are probably, and many of your audience are probably going to be very familiar with these examples. Many of the companies are taking extended use as part of their responsibility or the use of their product is something that is encouraging and increasing in prevalence. Traditional ways of thinking about things is, once something’s sold, it’s someone else’s problem. Actually, if you are needing or wanting to take responsibility after the consumer has the product, that creates all kinds of different incentives and decisions around quality and how long things last and whether it’s returnable, potentially sellable again.
This is happening in a bunch of industries. Peril is one of the ones that I cover a bit. Patagonia is obviously one of the most famous examples of this, where they have repair and secondhand marketplaces. That affects how they’re engineering and producing their products. The conceptual thing that I think is really important is for companies not just to think their responsibility ends when the product leaves their possession. It’s something that I am not someone who is always trying to boil things down to win-win, like, this is doing well by doing good.
Actually, there are examples where that works, but we need to be thinking about things like values, purpose, and responsibility as more of an ethical frame or regulation. I do think this is something where it’s a fundamental shift in how a business thinks about its relationship with its consumers. If it’s something where you have that ongoing relationship, the society where just someone has a shirt in the closet, I think it’s actually something that helps the company, its identity, its engagement with the consumer.

Now, I want to go back for a moment to your earlier work with the Better Business book. When we spoke about Better Business, you talked about the power of voluntary movements like B Corp certification, or, as you mentioned earlier in our conversation, being a benefit corporation. Has your thinking on that changed at all since writing that book?
I do not think a ton. I’ve come to see policy as much as I’ve come to see policy as a much more important lever if we’re going to actually affect those changes that I think we need to make in a world around things like climate inequality. Companies innovating and working together is a really essential part of trying to get to some of those policies. One of the things that I think is very interesting that I’ve come across a lot of examples of is where companies have legitimate intellectual property because of their mission, say, “We’re actually not going to patent this. Not going to, you know, we’re going to share the code because it’s aligned with their broader mission of public good.”
Companies innovating and working together is a really essential part of trying to get to policies that affect the changes we need around climate inequality.
One example I didn’t realize until recently, it connects to our discussion of shampoo bars. I guess Lush was the first company that had the shampoo bar, and there was discussion internally about patenting that idea of having shampoo in a bar. They realized this would be the exact opposite of what our mission is, and not only that, but then they actually open-sourced a variety of the formulas and ways of doing it so that other companies were able to do it. A lot of those examples of where companies are taking their innovation and making public goods is one area that I think needs more attention.
You could argue that Dr. Bronner’s got there first because they marketed their bars for everything from a very early time. I do not know if they would have been able to.
Maybe not. I do not know, Dr. Bronner. Good Dr. Bronner’s is doing that. I must say, I actually use Dr. Bronner’s soap and shampoo, which is liquid, actually. I’m a big fan.
I know. They’ve even marketed their bars for everything since the beginning of time. You could use it this way, and you could use it that way. I just do not like bar soap for my hair because when you rub it on your head, I do not know, you have like a special glove that you use or something like that to get it lathered and then put that on your hair. I just never enjoyed that process. I’ve tried numerous brands of these bar soaps. I will have bar shampoos. I would be very curious if you found one that you really like.
I’ve tried a number of them. When I was in the UK, I mean, I’m in the US where I spent a lot of time. I have Dr. Bronner’s at my home, but in the UK, you cannot get Dr. Bronner’s, so I would try a variety of different bar shampoos, and I cannot say they were all fine. I’m pretty low maintenance as far as my shampoos, so it was a variety of natural ingredient-type merchants from the UK. I cannot remember any of the names. They all worked very well. Davines, which is an Italian brand that I do not think is sold in the UK, but I’ve gotten their bar shampoos in the past, and that’s one that seemed to be pretty good.
I have not tried their bar. I do use Davines. I know they’re sold here. One of the things I do because I really like their NOU is, specifically for those watching, you might notice I’ve got some gray in my hair. The thing that’s irritating about gray hairs is that the texture can be different. Before I shifted to Davines, I think that’s how you say it. They’re an Italian brand that helped me with that texture difference.
My hair just feels good and does not look like it’s got the weird strand hanging out here without having to use additional products, like I do not really use hairspray or like gels or anything like that. I try to keep it minimal. I appreciate that about a very high-quality product. The other thing is that Davines is a B Corp. They also sell their product in refills. I can get the really big, minimal plastic refill item and just refill my containers. It’s not plastic-free; at least it’s less plastic. I like going in that direction.
Regenerative Agriculture: How Purpose-Driven Brands Restore Soil & Systems
This idea of companies working together that they’re also a great example of that. There’s this huge movement around regenerative agriculture. There’s a standard, the regenerative organic standard, which Dr. Bronner’s, Patagonia, and Rodale, who really is at the forefront of organic and regenerative agriculture, founded. Actually, I do not know how you pronounce it. Davines was part of that initial group. Actually, they worked very closely with Rodale.
One of Rodale’s, not that many, I mean, I think they have like, 5 to 10 around the world. One of their regenerative agriculture test sites is actually at Davines in Parma, Italy. This is an example of these companies, and they’re part of this beauty coalition, B Corp Beauty Coalition, which is trying to coordinate on packaging. The idea is that we’re all pretty small. We’re not L’Oréal or whomever. Let’s band together to try to actually have some market power on sustainability. They’re a great company that is involved in a lot of the collaboration and working together that I think is so important.
I’m glad that you brought up the Regenerative Organic Alliance and the ROC certification. There are foods available that are regenerative organic certified. Patagonia has a beer that is made with Kernza, which is a long-rooted grain that is being grown regeneratively and in test plots and beyond. There are just so many interesting projects. I never really understood at the very onset why Patagonia was championing regenerative organic. I loved it, I was like, “What’s the benefit? Why are they involved in this?” Now they make pastas and sardines and make all of these things available that are more responsibly sourced and that are better for you because they’re sourced with this intention.
It’s very interesting to have been following Patagonia for a number of years as well. That actually, when they got into some of the food business, they really came to have some understanding of if you actually do agriculture the right way, not the industrial type of agriculture that has come to dominate in the last hundred some years, but how people did it for probably thousands of years. It actually could be net positive for the world. Can rebuild soil, it could help with biodiversity, can help with community, build communities, people can have jobs.
Another book that I recommend is the biography of Yvon Chouinard. The founder of Patagonia by David Gelles. He’s a New York Times reporter. It’s called Dirtbag Billionaire. What Chouinard says in the book is that 50 years from now, Patagonia is perhaps only mainly a food company. It’s because that is a business where you can actually live the Patagonia values, so to speak, which is about saving our planet Earth. I have a lot of positive things to say about Patagonia. A frequent critique is that, actually, a lot of their products use fossil fuels. The various high-performance polyesters, like, I’m not exactly sure what it is.
Let’s be real, almost all of them.
This is Patagonia. It’s 100% regenerative cotton. I do think a lot. I have a number of Patagonia jackets, of course.
The fact that they’ll repair them for life, like my husband has a cotton work jacket that was gifted to him as an employee of Joby Aviation, where he works. He’s hard on this stuff. Engineer/mechanic/motorcycle guy, right? He’s hard on his stuff. The collar was getting tattered, and it had holes in it. How they addressed that instead of replacing the collar was stitching over it so much in the same color, just with string basically. It completely made it invisible, and it lays the way it should have. It was just an incredibly novel use of a sewing machine, in my opinion. It solved it. It looks great now.
I’ve had a variety of things. Because I teach in Patagonia and I studied it, if I have something wrong, I would definitely send it back. I’ve also been impressed with their repairs.
I feel the need to clarify why that book would be called Dirtbag Billionaire by everybody. I know that sounds like an insult. It’s not because specifically if you’re in the mountain climbing, mountaineering world, dirtbag is an affectionate term for other rock climbers, mountain climbers. It was really a provocative title, which I think you need to sell a book. Also, I have high regard for Yvon Chouinard. I appreciate that he has essentially made the company a corporation accountable to Earth. He’s been very creative in how he architected that. I had hoped that Ben and Jerry’s would have done something similar. Now they’re in a forever battle with Magnum ice cream.
Two lessons, I mean, the book is really great because it tells the story historically, and the world is changing during that time period. You can see how even this plant, where Patagonia was this huge innovator and celebrated for turning plastic bottles into fleece. That’s great. It turns out they have a lot of microplastic shedding problems. They’re like, “Geez.” They go through all kinds of processes of trying to solve and resolve that. There are so many of these areas where they are trying to do the best they can based on their values, but the world makes that very hard, and then how do they adjust and change? It was really valuable to see how a company that’s really being responsible is doing that.
Companies can be trying to do the best they can based on their values, but the world makes that very hard, and how they adjust and change is what matters.
Another thing that relates very much to Ben and Jerry’s is the importance of ownership. There’s a variety of different ownership forms. It’s unique in the US. In Denmark, it’s very popular. Other places are popular. They basically have a foundation own the company, and you can have it for a public purpose basically. Ben and Jerry’s were sold to Unilever, which probably seemed like a good bet at the time, but ended up creating lots of problems. Companies can sell to their employees, which Yvon Chouinard actually didn’t even trust. He thought that the employees might even change.
Look at what’s happening with REI lately. We tend to agree. REI is a co-op, and yet they’ve been betting against open spaces in a way where Patagonia is like, “No, like this is our vitality or everything.” They’re fighting for open spaces at every avenue possible. I want to close in a more hopeful way. Let me talk about building a regenerative economy and what actually works. The last part of your book is about building that regenerative economy with the commons in mind. What does that look like to you in practice?
Building A Regenerative Economy: Purpose-Driven Governance & Ownership
There’s a couple. First of all, there’s no silver bullet type of thing. This is something where the system is set up as through many examples we’ve talked about, from the Patagonia example to a lot of lobbying that exists. There are many things that need to be done. Ownership is key to this. If the way public ownership is set up, it orients companies to the short term. Variety of things, be it foundation, think there are examples of employee ownership.
Ownership is really important. Governance standards are also important. We also talked about benefit corporations. There’s a variety of other ways that purpose can be infused in boards and decision-making processes. The rules and laws of the company, I think, are another important aspect of that. Leadership is also important in whom you choose as a leader.
You mentioned the GE succession and how the people who were refused that specific role went on to ruin other companies. It’s just so poetic and terrible.
You should really follow people, James McNerney, think of his name. He went on to 3M. 3M is famous for having all these innovations, like sticky pads and other things, because people had a lot of slack in their work schedule, so they could do things that were creative. He squoze all that slack out and created all kinds of problems with 3M. He went on to Boeing, where they also focus on engineering innovation and have had these 737 MAX problems. The short-term leadership short-termism.
Something from Jack Welch is definitely not good, is pretty destructive and extractive. There are some things I think about. Governance ownership, leadership at the company level. There’s consumer, although I do think, as we talked earlier, it’s much more of a systems problem that we need to be focusing on laws and the really bad actors like the fossil fuel companies or the packaging companies. We all, as individuals, need to be doing our part as well.

We can also take some examples from some of the more creative politicians that we’re seeing out there, like Mayor Mamdani. We’re told, like New York, there’s no way they’ll balance their budget, and the things he’s promising are not doable. What happens? He got in there, and he started actually making changes that are affecting the lives of New Yorkers in a positive way. It does take leadership, and it feels to me like the American business system has gotten quite lazy in what it considers leadership. We need to be really putting more stock and weight.
Those visionaries like Yvon Chouinard were just like, “There’s got to be a better way, and I’m going to find it.” That uncompromising ethic of “I will find a better way.” Patagonia, you mentioned the polar fleece issues. Polar fleeces shed a lot of microplastics. One of the things they did to address that is sell with every polar fleece a bag that you were supposed to launder your polar fleece in so that the microfibers didn’t make their way. The end of the storm drains, which is helpful. It’s not a 100% solution. It’s a creative, helpful piece.
How many people would use them? You do not know. There are a lot of questions. Always seeking to make things a little better, it’s a quality that leaders should embody. Too often, we’re just extractive, more for the bottom line, more profits for the company. Not thinking about the impact on the community and the greater world. We need to get back to that. Probably the types of change that you and I are advocating for are not likely to happen in the next couple of years. In fact, we’ve seen the reverse of that with loosening restrictions on things like glyphosate, including PCBs, dioxins, and pesticides. Why not just go ahead and dump them on our food sources? That’s great. That’s the bleak end of it.
We were supposed to end on a positive note.
There is a positive note here. The bigger thing is that it can feel a lot like we do not have agency. The agency we do have is to make better choices in our daily lives, elect people who are going to care about the environment, our shared environments, social systems, support for the people, all of these things, and really think about what our role can be in that process. I’m hopeful because people who listen to this show or who read your work and follow your Substack and read The Profiteers, this could essentially be part of the wave and movement to help people think differently about what it takes to build a responsible business, to help people think differently about what it means to have a triple bottom line and why that’s important.
Whether or not you go through the effort of becoming a B Corp right away or a benefit corporation out of the gate, these avenues are available to you. Can think more creatively. We can do better day by day. There are really good examples out there like that. Even those like Dr. Bronner’s, who have since eschewed the B Corp as a certification because they feel like they’re doing so much better and do not like being in class with Nestle Health Science as an example. I understand and respect their decision. At the same time, I think B Corp does a lot of good for these other companies trying to live a little better, giving them the frameworks that they need to head in the right direction. Any tools or closing thoughts you’d provide to the audience?
Nothing specific. I do really appreciate our discussion and all the work that you do. Please, people should feel free to follow me in the various places, LinkedIn, my Substack, and feel free to be in touch with any questions or examples they may have.
Thank you so much for joining me. Thank you for your work. You’re referenced in my dissertation.
Thank you.
One of your peer-reviewed journal articles I had to go back to.
Those citations are very important to us academics.
Being referenced, you’ve helped guide my thinking. Whether or not you knew that heading into this. I appreciate you. I appreciate your work. Thank you so much for joining me.
Great. Thanks so much, Corinna. I really enjoyed our discussion.
—
Conclusion & Takeaways: Empowering Individual Action and Policy Reform
I mentioned to all of you that I follow Chris’s Substack. I will say I get articles almost every day. There’s often a roadmap for what a specific story is about. He will go ahead and highlight a regenerative story and an art form almost. Reflecting back on somebody he’s interviewed in a specific segment or something to that effect. I really enjoy the fact that he helps me stay apprised of what’s happening in the research world and also the news around the globe, the positives and the negatives.
It keeps my headset on and keeps me informed. I’ll include links to that and all of his social channels with show notes, as well as links to the book, The Profiteers and Better Business. Both are incredible reads. They’re very informative and will get you thinking creatively about how you can build better. Before we go, a word about this show’s cause partner, Prescott College, where I’ve just completed the requirements for my PhD in sustainability education. For 60 years, they have trained leaders in a co-learning, experiential environment to really think more systemically, act with integrity, and hold power accountable to the commons.
That spirit runs straight through this conversation. I’m proud to support them, and in honor of their 60th anniversary, I’ve been giving them a supplemental $60 donation every month. That’s in addition to the tuition I paid. You can find details at CareMoreBeBetter.com/Support. Thank you, audience, now and always, for being a part of this pod and this community.
As we close, I hope you’ll remember to ask deeper questions and understand that the true cost of goods you’re paying is not necessarily what you pay when you tap, swipe, or lay bills on the table. The bill for cheap goods always comes due, and we all pay the costs one way or another. It’s up to all of us to choose better when we can and to push our lawmakers to build the regulations and push the externalities of enterprise back onto The Profiteers. Thank you.
Important Links
- Christopher Marquis
- Christopher Marquis on LinkedIn
- Christopher Marquis on Substack
- Christopher Marquis on X
- Better Business: How the B Corp Movement is Remaking Capitalism
- The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profit and Socializes Cost
- University of Cambridge Judge Business School
- Bad Blood
- Incorruptible
- Beyond Plastics
- The Problem with Plastic
- Dirtbag Billionaire
- Prescott College
- B Corp: Creating A Movement To Build Better Businesses With Chris Marquis – Previous Episode
- Solving The Problem Of Plastic Pollution With Judith Enck – Previous Episode
- Care More Be Better Support
Author
-
View all posts
Corinna is a natural products industry executive who has earned a reputation for leading the development and growth of responsible brands (e.g. Nordic Naturals, iwi, NutriGold). In her professional life, she champions social benefit programs to enhance company impact while preserving and protecting our home planet. She’s presently working tirelessly on the development of a new pre-market that seeks to achieve a carbon-negative impact. In January 2021 she launched her show, Care More, Be Better: A Social Impact + Sustainability Podcast to amplify the efforts of inspired individuals and conscious companies. Through Care More Be Better, she shares their stories in an effort to show us all that one person with one idea can have a big impact. As part of her lifelong education journey, she earned her MBA from Santa Clara University, graduating at the top of her class with a triple focus in Entrepreneurship, Leadership and Marketing in June 2021.